Make a debate class but the assessment will be applied individually. XII IPA 6 and 7 as a pro position, while XII IPS 1 and 2 as a contra one.
The motion is "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom".
Write your opinion on the comment box!
The motion is "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom".
Write your opinion on the comment box!
Adin Martdhanna XII-S1/03
BalasHapusI think, it's okay if we have meal in the classroom, because it can save time. The students could lose time to have meal in the canteen when the canteen was crowded. Therefore school must allow student to have meal in the classroom, if school doesn't allow that condition, there should be add some canteen capacity.
Thank you^^
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII-S2 / 12
BalasHapus+1 for adin.
as we know that our cafeteria room's size is not too large. whether that room can contain all of SMA 2's students who want to eat?
Could you imagine what will happen if the rule that doesn't allow us to have meal in the classroom?
do we have to wait for another students to finish their meal? in fact, our break time is just 15 minutes...
This is only my opinion... thank you :)
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII-S2 / 12
BalasHapusNo more comment !
Thank you (",)~
Discussion closed .
:D
Novia Senja Kurnia XII-S2 / 22
BalasHapusSchools should also at the circumstances of each students in grade XII,students must have his reason why he eats in the class.moreover that many students who had not time to breakfast at home because of additional classes in the morning at school.I think that students should simply have learned and provided that the waste from discarded food wrapper instead of garbage.
Arinta Nur Setya Sari XII-S2 / 09
BalasHapusI'm from the contra group. In my opinion, should be allowed to eat in class. Because the breaks are only 15 minutes, it's clearly not enough for students. Because they have to queue up in advance, otherwise service in the cafeteria is not quickly also became a problem for students. The students who bring food to class, they had to throw trash in its place, not under the bench. For students in grade 3, they need more rest time for breakfast. And circumstances make them bring food into the classroom. If they continue to eat in the cafeteria, they will get punishment from the teacher for being late to class. It's a fact that occurred. Thank you !!
OVI BUDI WIDIANTO
BalasHapusXII SOCIAL 2
i'm agree with adin and dwi,and i want just added comment about that,,at the fact many student,bring the meal in to the class,and if any rule School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom,it will make the student come late to the classroom,and how,if the teacher is killer,and don't care anything about student,,the student will get the point,because it,,so,if we must go to canteen first,we will come late to the class.And i think,school must allowed the student meal in the classroom,with one rule,when the student had finished mel,the student must throw the rubbish in the garbage,and forbid student throw the garbage in the underneath table,and student must keep the clen of classroom.
MOHAMMAD RIDWAN FAUZI /XII IPS 2 / 18
BalasHapusI think the school does not have to decide the issue with one hand, because students are also citizens entitled to ask for negotiations or proposed school, especially a problem in the lift a ban on eating in the classroom. Schools must provide a way out if this policy will be on the run, if I look at eating in class is a tradition that has been passed down in our schools so that if we want to do away with the process should be exactly that does not make students feel surprised by the policy ini.bila students are not mentally ready to accept many things that bother you, as a lesson and activity each student's own. thus providing the right solution for example by increasing the hours of rest so that students can ore can enjoy the food.
Ardhini Galuh Ika Wardani XII.IS2 / 7
BalasHapusI agree with Novia Senja, because if it is forbidden to bring food to class, we will feel bored. as the limited capacity of the school canteen, if we are forbidden to bring food to class, we will find a difficulty to have breakfast. moreover, break time is not too long it will make us in a hurry.
NINDRI YASTUTI
BalasHapusFROM : XII SOCIAL II
I strongly agree with the opinions of friends over, and I think there is no reason for schools to prohibit students to bring food into the classroom, the reason is always in use by teachers is because of the cleanliness class, but do not know the condition of school students? , Students were given only 15 minutes to go to the canteen while the distance Atara cafeteria with live classrooms in far enough, then if the teacher is a teacher who does not tolerate delay, while for the rest of the two usually used by students to pray, if prohibit school students to bring food into the classroom, the school should also be able to give students an alternative option to the problem above, in addition to the main problem is fear of disruption of school hygiene class, it is the mentality of the individual, and school should be able to provide understanding as well as examples that can lead students to be able to maintain the cleanliness of the class they occupy.
I guess that's all from my opinion .
Fatimatuz Zahro fi Ramadhan
BalasHapusXII IPS 2
I do not agree with the statement. because as we have seen, that students at our school has a thousand students. while the capacity at our canteen is not possible to accommodate all. Given this limitation, the scope narrows students to eat their food in the classroom, because of inadequate canteen full. besides, if the second break we use to buy food in the cafeteria, of course, the student can not perform obligatory worship. whereas the time to worship only thirty minutes. if we do both, of course, we'll be late back to class.
if we care about cleanliness class, at least we can provide the trash in front of their classes and provide sanctions for those who violate. I think, that's all from my opinion.
leila Faranazt
BalasHapusXII-S2 / 16
I agree with my friends opinion. we know that da duration of da break in SMAN 2 Lumajang only 15 minutes which can be fairly brief because da canteen is located outside da high skool building which resulted in da 15 minutes is'nt long enough to buy food 'n spend it in da breaks time. other than that I think it's perfectly natural if da students eat in da base class does'nt pollute da waste generated due to class after a meal.
Ariek Prihandini (no 8)
BalasHapusXII-IPS 2
I agree with fatimah's opinion...
If we are forbidden to meal in the classroom, We will come late to the class. As we know, break time in the school is not enough for us to eat, meal, and refreshing. In the other side, our teacher always sue us to comke in time, or we get punishment.
In the fact, meal also can help person and increase their focus when they have lesson. Our brain will work maximally when we are in relax condition. Don't be so tense.........
Luhung Widoutomo XII-S1/18
BalasHapusI agree with Adin opinion if the canteen was crowded and not too large.
Many students bring food provisions, they can't eat food provisions in canteen, so the students have meal in the classroom and dirt leftovers can discarded in wastebasket every classroom.
So can save time and money
I think, it's okay
Abrar Raditya XII-S1/02
BalasHapusI don't agree with that mentioned in this topic, we see in many developed countries, eat in a class that only allowed, and instead is very in proposing, in the learning process, students should be able to relax and ease of learning, such as eating in class
thank's...
VERDY FIRMANTORO
BalasHapusXII IPS 2
The motion is trully AGAINST the HUMAN RIGHT. It belongs to unimportant rule which makes students as victims. Why they are still busy with the "EATING MATTER"??? since it doesn't have any effect to the STUDENTS' ACHIEVEMENT...
We can see in another country that the students or even the teacher can smoke inside the class. However, they still have a good intelligence instead of the controversial habit. So, lets not talk about THE STRICT RULE only, but lets think about how to EDUCATE the students well.THANK YOU....
DISTANIA SANTOSO
BalasHapusXII-S1 / 10
Hi everyone,
I strongly disagree with the topic, as we know in our school cafetaria is not large enough to accommodate the entire of school community. Besides, if all citizens of the school break in the same time (just 15 minutes) , same place, and with a rumbling stomach, you know.. that the comfortable will not be happening. And conversely, hot conditions will be created there.
And, I have some solution if this policy had to be applied.
The solution are, the school's headmaster and the all of the teacher should be able to direct the canteen's committe to provide the best service for all citizen in the school, and not only that, but also provide AC, so the students feel comfortable while in the school cafetaria.
Okay, thats all my opinion + solution for this case :D
LILIK SUCI CENDRANI
BalasHapusXII - IPS - 01 / 17
Good evening,ladies and gentleman
Thankyou for the opportunity that given to me.
I am from contra group .
From the motion ,I disagree that "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom".
As we know, in our school we have just two alternative place to have meal, canteen or classroom
However, a number of students in SMADA greater than capacity in the canteen.
We can imagine how stuffy canteen at the time when the break time bell was sound.
Many students queue to get food and remember that break time in SMADA JUST 15 minute .
If school does not allow students to have meal in the classroom.
the possibility :
1. the students will come late to the class
because students queue for a long time to get food and place in the canteen
2. the students will be famished and cannot focus to the lesson
because they have not opportunity to have meal in the canteen where very crowded
thank you!
angga rahadi s XII S1/5
BalasHapusi don't agree with the statement that "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom"
because, the capacity of our canteen is very limited with much student and break time in SMADA JUST 15 minute. so, this could make students late to class if the student did not get a seat in the cafeteria.
and the way to prevent it is to eat in the classroom as long as rubbish dumped in the trash.
thank you...
MOCHAMAD CHOIRUL UMAM XII IPS 2 / 17
BalasHapusHi friend . . .
I am from the contra group . I really disagree with that motion . I think the motion is insane , how a school cafeteria can accommodate all SMADA’s students in a short break time . so that , the students can bring the food into the class . in the other side , if there are many students in cafeteria , the condition of the cafeteria will be hot and dirty . condition like that make students uncomfortable to eat in the cafeteria .and if the students can bring the food into the class , they have to put the rubbish into the dustbeen .
that’s all my opinion about the motion , thank you .
MUHAMMAD IQBAL PAMBUDI
BalasHapusXII IPS 2 / 19
Hello every body..
I’m Iqbal from the contra group.
I don’t agree with the rule that make students can’t bring the food in to the class. I think the cafeteria in smada is narrow, it makes the cafeteria so crowd. That condition is uncomfortable for students to eat something. If the students don’t like that, they can bring their food in to the classroom, with consequence, after they eat the food, they have put the rubbish in to the dustbin. If they don’t do that they have to put the rubbish in to a container and put it into their bag, they can take it home or throw the rubbish in to the dustbin out side the school.
I think that all my opinion..
Thank you..
MOCHAMAD CHOIRUL UMAM XII IPS 2 / 17
BalasHapusHi friend . . .
I am from the contra group . I really disagree with that motion . I think the motion is insane , how a school cafeteria can accommodate all SMADA’s students in a short break time . so that , the students can bring the food into the class . in the other side , if there are many students in cafeteria , the condition of the cafeteria will be hot and dirty . condition like that make students uncomfortable to eat in the cafeteria .and if the students can bring the food into the class , they have to put the rubbish into the dustbin .
that’s all my opinion about the motion , thank you .
DAUD JORDAN ADHA/XII-S2/11
BalasHapusI’m from pro group,I disagree with the motion about that because I think eating in the class is more comfortable than in the canteen,on the other side eating in the class can save time for student so they can use the time for other activity like study.And also because of short break time can hamper the next lesson.But SMADA student should throw the rubbish into the dustbin.
This my opinion about the motion,Thanks.
DAUD JORDAN ADHA/XII-S2/11
BalasHapusI’m from contra group,I disagree with the motion about that because I think eating in the class is more comfortable than in the canteen,on the other side eating in the class can save time for student so they can use the time for other activity like study.And also because of short break time can hamper the next lesson.But SMADA student should throw the rubbish into the dustbin.
This my opinion about the motion,Thanks.
ADHYTIA PAHLAWAN XII IPS 2 / 02
BalasHapusAssalamu'Alaikum wr. wb
Hi guys..!,I'am adit from contra group, when I look a comment above me , I think I agree with that comment...,and I want to give some addition in that comment . I think about have meal in the class, it can make us arrive at class on time when the break time is over,so to avoid the delay of entry into the classroom , we don't need to go to out of class , we just have meal in the class.
besides that it also saves our cost, because we don't need to buy anything in the canteen,if we have ourself meal to eat in the class.
I think that's all my comment for now, i hope we will share many - many more arguments next time..thank you.
WINDA PRATAMI XIIS1/29
BalasHapushy all my friends,
i'm from contra group,
i disagree with the motion that "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom".
Cz if students have meal in the classroom wouldn't allow, the students wiil be stress.
how not?
our school had a cafeteria with a size that is not so great. While students at our school there are about 800 students. if you can imagine what would happen if forbidden to bring food in class? and if that happens, the canteen was so narrow that it will feel more and more narrow with a gathering of 800 students in such a narrow space. Coupled with the rest time is only 15 minutes. it can lead students into the class late and miss the lesson. and te teacher wil angry if any their students come late to the their class
it's my opinion, thank you,,,,, ^_^
Nur Indah Kurniawati
BalasHapusXII-S1 / 24
hi everyone..
i'm from contra group,
so i should to disagree with the motion that "school doesn't allow students to have meal in the classroom".
why? because i have any arguements:
1. Our school's canteen area is too little for accumulate all students when we have break time at same time. So, the condition inside that become hotter, noisy, and discomfortable to enjoy the meals.
2. Students only have 15 minutes to break. It's not enough time for students to walk from class to the canteen while the time have reduced by moving class.
caused both of that, some student choose to have meal in the classroom if they don't late. Because,it's more efective than have meal in the canteen. Because time is money. students must have suply energy to concentration in learning. So, why school doesn't allow students to have meal in the class event the students also have right to get better, comfort, and enjoy in the school as the Management quality of SMada is "mengembangkan dan memberdayakan semua potensi. Selalu melakukan perbaikan berkelanjutan guna memenuhi kepuasan pelanggan". So, i really contra with the motion. it is all. Thank you...
M. Yulianto
BalasHapusXII-S1 / 21
Assalamualaikum .. i'm from contra grup. I disagree with the school's policy about "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom". because in my opinion, the policy is actually made, only to avoid waste disposal is not in place, especially in the classroom. if it brings in the classroom can lead to food waste, it depends on the students. students can maintain the cleanliness or not.
Sulistyowati
BalasHapusXII S1 / 28
Hi Boys n Girls,
I come from contra group,
i think, I disagree with the policy, especially for class XII students. we have to leave early for the course and did not get to eat breakfast so instead we bring food to school. Surely it's the food we eat in the classroom because the cafeteria was closed. Also during recess we had to walk a long way towards the cafeteria, until in the canteen we still have to queue to buy food separately. So we are not comfortable eating in the canteen because the capacity of a small canteen while the number of students nearly a thousand students, eventually we all just buy a cafeteria meal eaten alone and in the classroom. If we do not immediately go back to class then we will be late due to a little rest time.
i think enough,
thank you....
Dyah Paramudita Raharjo
BalasHapusXII-S1/12
Assalamu'alaikum wr.wb
Haii everybody...
I'm from contra group.
I strongly disagree with the motion..
Because, the capacity in the SMADA's canteen is not enough to accomodate all of the students. Usually, a part of the student bring their own food to avoid queue in a long time when break time. We can imagine, how if the students didn't have meal in the classroom? Should they must gather in one place??
In the fact, sometime.. buyers could not got seat in there (canteen). Actually, that things spent our break time. Whereas, the time only 15 minutes.
I think that's my opinion..
Thanks :)
Dwi Septin Putri Radite
BalasHapusXIIS1/11
oke,i am from contra group.
i guess our shcool shoul allow us to have meal in the class based on the mossion.
my opinion is, if the school allow us to have meal in the class we wouldn't be late to arrive in the class during the sparetime. and we can do some other thinks in the same times if we have meal in the class. most of the student bring their own food.so it will be more efficient if they eat in their class.
BRIANT SUDWI JULYAN
BalasHapusXII S1/07
Assalamualaikum Wr.Wb
Hello Friends
I’m Briant from the group contra ...
I dont agree with the mention that make the students cant bring food to class.Because, in my opinion these mention are too onerous burden of students in meetingone of the conditions in concentration in the receiving subject matter of the teacher is BREAKFAST. Moreover, we have third class that will soon face the exams that determine the future course students after graduating senior high school. Which makes me not agree with that rule because of the lack of rest hoursimposed by the school after morning classes. Not to mention we are often punished by the teacher for being late entered the classroom and distanceclass to the cafeteria which is too time consuming because of the access door to the cafeteria on the east which is always closed in the morning. Therefore, I plead with the teacher to understand that situation. And we as students of SMADA will try to minimize the spread of junk food wrappers that we had broughtand always dispose of trash takeout in the space provided. And for students of SMADA, it would be nice to bring food from home in packaging that can be used repeatedly as a plastic food boxes to minimize the spread of trash. So that I can say, thank you...
Wassalamualaikum Wr.Wb
hesti ika agustin
BalasHapusXIIS1/01
i am from contra group.
i disagree with the motion that school's policy about "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom" because if students are forbidden to eat in a class that happens is that students are late to follow the next lesson if all the students eat in the canteen. at the canteen during recess it was crowded with students who want to eat there. and not a few students who are punished because late to class by reason of eating in the canteen. so it would not hurt if students take and eat in the classroom during class students were able to keep clean and discard the rest of the food in the trash
naufal afif
BalasHapusXII sains 6 / 16
assalamualaikum wr. wb.
I think, I am the first person who comment for pro about the topic...
I agree with the motion, because there are some reasons why have meal in the classroom does not allowed:
1. If we have meal in the classroom,it will make the classroom dirty, because most of us (the student of Senior High school 2 lumajang) often throw the rubish anywhere, sometimes we throw the rubish under the table.
2.if we have meal in the classroom, make a classrom bad smell, so we will uncomfortable with the bad smell
I think enough for today..
thank you
Lukmahendra
BalasHapusXIIS1/ 19.
Assalamu'alaikum wr.wb
I'm from contra group.
I would respond to a statement saying the school has a policy to prohibit students eating in class.
I do not agree if the school has a policy to prohibit students to eat in class. we know it today students Grade 12th have entered the school at 5:30 in the morning to attend morning tutoring program in the school. we know a lot of 12th graders did not take the time to have breakfast at home because they fear late when the lessons began. so many of them students 12th grade
buy food in the school cafeteria or outside the school for breakfast. students 12th Grade usually breakfast when they are finished the morning lessons. and many of them students grade 12th breakfast in the classroom. I therefore disagree over school policy that prohibits students to eat in class. because it is burdensome for 12th graders. and the school should provide alternative
so as not to burden the students grade 12 in terms of breakfast or eat in the classroom
Anas Abbin Bahar
BalasHapusXII-S2 / 5
sorry, i don't agree with the statement. i think when our school wants to do that, the committee should have considered to enlarge the canteen. coz we know that our canteen will not be able to accommodate us all. sometimes i feel uncomfortable in the canteen. there are too much people there, it's so crowded.
and if our school is afraid of being dirty with our plastics, an obligation should be made. like, giving some sentences for those who dont put garbage in its place.
Faiz Syarifuddin Rizqi XII IPS 2 / 13
BalasHapusResponding to comments from Naufal Afif from the Pro group, I think it's less true because I see everyday lots of the students are starting to be aware of the environment. As a friend we can also remind him/her of it (throw the rubbish under table). So what's the harm if we bring food into the class if it's more helpful for the students, for example it can saves time because it doesn't have to be queued to eat in the canteen and it can also prevent delays when entering the lessons like what said by Adhyt, Putri and the others
thank you..
RIAN YUNIAR RAHMAD
BalasHapusXII-S1/27
Assalamualaikum Wr Wb
I'm from contra group ,I don't agree with the motion is "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom".
I think eating in class is okay because, most students bring lunch from home so don't need to buy another meal in the cafeteria. and also to save the rest time in the given time only 15 minutes. packs of food must be provided in the exhaust in place and not in place under the table.
so the conclusion in my opinion is okay to eat in class but did not take place during school hours and also does not pollute the class.
Naufal Afif
BalasHapusXII Sains 6
I want to argue Faiz Syarifuddin's argument, I know that aware of environment of the student increase, but in the fact still there are many persons who throw the the rubish in everywhere, and one of the caused of it is the student have meal in the classroom.
thanks
NUR CHAMIDAH
BalasHapusXII-S2/23
I disagree with that rule, as we know, the first break time just 15 minutes, and sometime although the bell ring teacher still cntinue the lesson, so when we go to canteen, we just find crowdied studens...and our solution just bring some snack to the class.
and for the last break time interrupted with time to pray dhuhur, but the problem, when we take wudhu...we must stand in line for along time, so often we late enter to the class, we just buy some snack and bring it to the class
NOVI MILIANA
BalasHapusXII-S2/ 21
I'm contra with rule "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom". if we prohibited eat in the classand where we should eat?, as we knowas, the canteen is insufficient to accommodate all students, da seating capacity is also very kurang.senebtara terrace outside the classroom was not too broad, and only provided a few seats only.
so each class should be provided mugkin bins and picket schedule must be set for more efficient
NUR CHAMIDAH
BalasHapusXII-S2/23
i want to respond naufal statement..
i thik it still can be overcome,for example: at the time of initial entry into the class we throw away the rubbish in a desk drawer in to the garbage, sometimes teachers are also reminded that, and it was very influential .. compared to prohibit students eating in class, often even at rest time we still do some assignment, such as preparation for presentation, and if we are forbidden to eat in the classroom, certainly just make difficult for those students
M. YULIANTO
BalasHapusXII S1 / 21
Assalamu'alaikum...
i want to argue Naufal Afif's argument, if you say That the student still there are many persons who throw the rubish in everywhere, that means it depends on the students.
could have students don't bring food in the classroom, but in the canteen. if it can't keep clean, they are also throw the rubish in everywhere, includin around the canteen.
because that, it must be kept clean, but not necessarily with such a policy,
could have given a penalty.
because if we bring the food in the classroom can save time, do not have to go to the canteen
so students can bring food in the classroom by keeping clean.
SULISTYOWATI
BalasHapusXII S1 / 28
You can argue it that way because it allows your own habits.
if we are not allowed to bring food in the classroom, is it enough rest time just 15 minutes if we have to go back to the cafeteria if we bring their own lunch.
whereas, if we do not bring lunch, we had to queue to buy food in the cafeteria. I think if that was not enough and that takes time.
thank you
SULISTYOWATI
BalasHapusXII S1 / 28
i want to argue naufal afif's argument.
You can argue it that way because it allows your own habits.
if we are not allowed to bring food in the classroom, is it enough rest time just 15 minutes if we have to go back to the cafeteria if we bring their own lunch.
whereas, if we do not bring lunch, we had to queue to buy food in the cafeteria. I think if that was not enough and that takes time.
thank you
MEILINA TRI WULANDARI
BalasHapusXII-S1 / 20
Hello everybody,
I’m from contra group.
I disagree if there is a rule that not allowed to bring meal in the classroom. the reason is because many students who bring food from home, therefore we are eating in the classroom. if forbidden to eat in the classroom and forced to eat in the canteen then the result is we have to queue and take turns to eat there, because existing capacity is inadequate in the canteen with the number of students there. although as students purchase snack foods or heavy meals in the canteen many of those who eat in the classroom because we are at school recess time is limited. Our first break only 15 minutes, plus we had to queue to buy food with the students throughout the school. and if we are forbidden to eat in the classroom, then we can not eat in the canteen because of limited space available, therefore we could not got our comfortable there.
AYU ROSA W . XII.IPS.1 . 06
BalasHapusassalamualaikum wr wb.
Hello my friends from the Group counter will respond to a topic in this case.
I disagree with this topic saying that prohibits school students bring food in the classroom. My reason is because as we know that our canteen is too large in size are not, so it is not possible to accommodate all the students to eat there. In addition, the break at school we seemed very poorly by existing queued to buy the food, sometimes many students who have not had time to eat but the Bell entry already says. So, indirectly they will bring the food in the classroom because they feel should still fill his stomach and it too they do so they are not in preceded teachers who will teach.
So, I very much disagree when carrying food in the classroom, because it is so prohibited are not effective in the circumstances.
so this is my opinion ...
Thank you. :)
RARA SAVIRA FILAILY
BalasHapusXII-S1/26
hi..
i'm from contra group..
i want to argue naufal afif statements..
you said, that if we have meal in the classroom, the class will be dirty.
i think, that's not irrasional. because, the students already have a high sense of responsibility. they will not throw their garbage everywhere. in addition, there's a lot of trash outside the classroom. so, the classroom will stay clean..
thank's..
i think, that's all..
YOLANDA MERANI XII.S1 / 30
BalasHapusHello friend..
I'm from contra group.
I disagree about the motion because if we can't bring food into the class whereas the break only 15 minutes, and we still have to queue up in the cafeteria. In addition, where provided in the cafeteria is very narrow so it is not possible for all students eat in the cafeteria. and when it is not allowed to bring food in the classroom, what about students who bring food from home? whether to take their food in the cafeteria as well?
so if we don't bring meal in the classroom, isn't effective to student.
it is my opinion.
thank you :D
Rara Savira Filaily
BalasHapusXII-S1/26
i want to argu Naufal Afif statement..
You said, that there is still a lot of garbage everywhere because students have meals in class. but, they can clean up the garbage right? therefore, made a list of pickets that make the students want to clean the classroom. so, not a problem if students eat their meals in the classroom.
that's it..
thank's..
MUCHAMAD REZA ISMAWAN XII-S1/22
BalasHapusHello Everyone . . .
I'm from contra group
I disagree with that motion because students like to bring lunch from home and most students complain with food in the canteen. moreover, the cafeteria with class distance is too far away so that students become lazy to eat in the cafeteria and would prefer to eat in class. besides the food menu in the canteen are monotone make the students become bored. The last one I hope that the policy is not realized.
thank you . . .
Sesar Prabu Dwi S. XIIA6/26
BalasHapusassalamualaikum wr.wb.
at the first, i'm sorry i disagree with the statement any person who contra with this policy. They said that the smada's students could keep the classroom cleaness by throw the meal waste to the dustbin. but in fact, althought school doesn't allow students to have meal in the classroom, there are a lot of meal waste in the classroom, especially in the desk. it is one of the reason why school prohibit students to have meal in the classroom...
thank you.
pandu maulana n.
BalasHapusXIIA6/20.
asslamualaikum wr. wb.
in this time, we've to go back with the main function of the class. class is a room to study, class a room for us to get subjects. class is not place to eat. school have provided canteen (new canteen) for us to eat at breaking time, this canteen have large place. in hope, students can use this canteen as its function.
thanks you.
Hellylintarum Idsug Wardani XII-A6/07
BalasHapusi'm from pro group.
i want to argu Rara Savira statement.
you say that we can clean the garbage under the bench by the list of pickets. but, we can't always clean the garbage because in our school conducts moving program. we can't always clean the class which we occupy and it can spend our time to study.
and i want to add Naufal's argument.
i think, canteen is a place which use for eat all of students. so we must use the function well. for what canteen if all the students eat in the classroom?
Lukita Qirotul Ayunin XIIA6/13
BalasHapusassalamualaikum wr. wb
I'm in line with Sesar, I think students in smada still don't have responsibility to keep the class clean. many ways have done by teacher to increase the responsibility of students but in fact, students still throw the rubbishes anywhere the want. I feel so bad when I look many rubbishes in the slope, so I agree if school does not allow students to have meal in the classroom. thank you
Rendy Permana Putra/XIIA6/23
BalasHapusassalamualaiku wr. wb.
I want to add a statement of nouval afif, because I think eating in the classroom can make the classroom to become dirty. With a relatively short rest periods, the students did not have time to dispose of waste in place and then they throw garbage in the classroom. Moving class system allows the students do not perform picket list. consequently garbage will pile up in class, especially on the bench so the class becomes dirty and uncomfortable to use learning. Therefore, we should eat in the cafeteria. there was a janitor who will clean up our food waste in the cafeteria. Other than that by eating in the canteen we can meet our friends from other classes. This will make our mind fresh again.
thank's
Wassalamualaikum wr. wb.
Lukita Qirotul Ayunin XIIA6/13
BalasHapusI agree with Helly's statement, we can't always make our friend in the picket list clean our rubbishes, it make our time is not efficient. we must wait our friend clean the class and it make we spend our time to study and then we're in the moving class, it's difficult to keep the class clean if we just count on our friend in the picket list.
Anggi aditama
BalasHapusXII IPA-6/01
Assalamualaikum Wr.Wb.
Before this I'm sorry because I do not agree with the opinion cons.
Basically even grade school hygiene is the responsibility of all citizens of the school.
Prohibition to not eat in the classroom is very appropriate to be applied, and I am sure that not all of the students throw food wrap used in the trash.
So it should if the students eat in the classroom please dispose of trash in its place
THANKS...
NAME : AYU FITRI MURDIATY
BalasHapusCLASS: XIIA6-03
assalamualaikum mr trisno ...........
and to all my friend
i'm in pro group.. :D
first, i want to say 'bout the rules of the school. we all know that the rules must be obeyed by every people in school area..
then.. if there are rules 'School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom'so we must obey it.
i think if we bring meal from canteen to classroom is not good because can make our class dirty and make us not enjoyed in the class..
as a good student we must eat foods in the canteen to appreciate the function of canteen..
I think this is only temporary it will be my next fix again
wassalam
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII-S2 / 12
BalasHapus-> Naufal Afif <-
" 1. If we have meal in the classroom,it will make the classroom dirty, because most of us (the student of Senior High school 2 lumajang) often throw the rubbish anywhere, sometimes we throw the rubbish under the table.
2.if we have meal in the classroom, make a classroom smells so bad, so it will be uncomfortable for us
I want to ask about your statement .
The point of your statement is : " if student have meal in the class, the student will make the classroom dirty and have a bad smell " .
correct me if i'm wrong
1. So, are you sure that student who have meal in canteen can keep the canteen clean ? the student throw the rubbish into the dustbin ?
I don't think so. In fact, many students who have finished their meal just go away like that, leaving their craps where they eat. do you know who clean those craps??? yes, they are Canteen's employee itself. so is your statement can be proved??
PS : for your statement " (the student of Senior High school 2 lumajang) often throw the rubbish anywhere, sometimes we throw the rubbish under the table. "
2. and, what the difference between we have meal in the class and in the canteen ? If we throw the rubbish not in the proper place.
ok i think enough. Thanks .
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII-S2 / 12
BalasHapusNb :
I think my last post not only for Naufal afif, but also for all Pro Group.
as i know 90% argument from pro's group is same.
lol ._.
Sarah Mayashavirah
BalasHapusXIIS2
Assalamua'laikum ...
I'm from contra group,
I disagree if school forbade students to not bring food into the classroom.
Because I think if students of SMAN 2 Lumajang eat in the cafeteria, canteen room capacity we are inadequate. So some students have to bring food into the classroom. And I think eating in the classroom feels more comfortable than eating in the cafeteria. Moreover, the current class XII students have morning lessons are held by the school. So many students who bring food from home because no time for breakfast and breakfast should be eaten in the classroom, because there is no other place. Moreover, if all students are aware of the cleanliness class, they certainly will not throw food waste arbitrarily.
Thank you...
sesar prabu dwi s. XIIA6/26
BalasHapusi agree with pandu's opinion, because in moslem there is law that command the moslem people to use everything based on its function, and if we don't do it, it's mean that we "dhalim"...
So, we must use everything based on its function...
thank you..
sesar prabu dwi s. XIIA6/26
BalasHapusi want to ask Dwi Purnama Handoko...
So..what must we better to do?have meal in the classroom or buy some food and eat in the canteen??
Deni Ahmad Wiyanto
BalasHapusXII S1 / 08
when eating in class is not allowed, whereas when we look at the facts, the less rest time, it has been proven, and when eating in class was banned, what can we learn well with a hungry stomach??
thank you
AHMAD NAUFAL
BalasHapusXII SOCIAL 1
I think bringing lunch to school to eat does not matter because it is not difficult for students to carry and also because the remote location of the canteen of the class will make students prefer to eat their lunch from home. thus bringing lunch to school very well and did not make the grade to be dirty.
Thank you...
Abrar Raditya
BalasHapusXII S1 / 02
i want argue naufal afif opinion
exactly when the problem of waste and odor from the garbage itself, what is the obstacles that make students hungry during the lesson?
It could all be in control, it takes discipline very high, and habituation of each individual regarding the trash
thank you.
vivian nindya eliansyah
BalasHapusXII S2 / 30
eating in class was actually allowed, only in accordance with applicable rules, polite, and keeping clean.
does not make sense, if there are students who can think calmly when hungry.
thank you
Novrisha Anggoro
BalasHapusXII A7/24
I think it is our rights whether we're having meal or not in the classroom. But, as what as vivian nindya eliansyah said that eating in class was actually allowed, it is not suitable with the proper rules that have been applied by many schools.
As students of SMA 2,we should have manner when we're having meal. It is more polite if we're having meal in the cafeteria than having meal in the classroom. Because the main function of classroom is to have lessons from the teachers not to have meal when we're hungry. We have to be able to manage ourselves not to be hungry in the classroom. If we can hold our hunger for more than 12 hours in fasting month and at that time we're having learning activities,why we can't hold our hunger just for a few hours.
Novrisha Anggoro
BalasHapusXII A7/24
I want to oppose Dwi Handoko opinion.
The rubbish in the canteen isn't matter, the most important thing is there is no rubbish in the classroom. But, awareness to be clean in everywhere should be applied in our daily life.
as what as i can take from Dwi Handoko opinion,having meal in the classroom is allowed. If we're talking about the fact,there's no doubt that there are many rubbish that caused by students who have meal in the classroom. If you (Dwi Handoko) can ensure that eating in the classroom is allowed, which rules of SMA2 that "having meal in the classroom is allowed" and everyone knows about it?
Novi Tri Nugraheni
BalasHapusXIIA6/18
Assalamualaikum
Ok, I'm from pro group, I have the same opinion with the pro group, I say it, because I have some reason,
1. If we bring a meal in the class, it make our class dirty, and we know, that in the class there isn't the place of trash, but the place of trash in outside the classroom, sometimes, the students lazy to throw the trash outside the class, and if the students doesn't have a awareness, they will throw the rubbish in desk.
2. we know that in smada, the class is moving, and if we leave a lot of garbage in the class then it will disturb the concentration of our study, and usually the teacher told us to picket or clean the class, it will reduce the time we learn in class.
Canteen should be used according to its function, as well as class.
Thanks..
Wassalamualikum
Novi Tri Nugraheni
BalasHapusXIIA6/18
I want to comment on Ahmad Naufal's opinion,
Actually it does not matter if we bring the meal in class, but it was not in place, because the function of the class is to learn, other than that if students do not have the awareness of the importance of cleanliness, they would be littering. In fact most students behave like that
ELAN FITRA Dianto
BalasHapusXII.S1/15
I think eating in class is okay as long as we can maintain the cleanliness of the classroom. and also by eating in the classroom, we can also share food with someone else and also can exchange food with another friend. and I also agree with his opinion Adin.
thank you
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII S2 - 12
BalasHapusBefore that, sorry for -> sesar prabu dwi s. <-
I won't / can't comment your argument.
because, your argument have a "..." ( can i called SARA ? ) :|
so, i'm so sorry for that :)
lol :3
btw, about your 2nd post ->
" So..what must we better to do?have meal in the classroom or buy some food and eat in the canteen?? "
you can check all my post in this web. maybe my post can answer your problem , and of course to answer this question :3
i think enough. feel free to ask / discuss about this issue / motion / bla" / etc
Thank you :)
Faiz Syarifuddin Rizqi XIIS2 / 13
BalasHapusI try to answer Sesar Prabu question " So..what must we better to do?have meal in the classroom or buy some food and eat in the canteen?? "
I think we are better to have meal in the classroom than in the canteen that very crowded when break time. It can also save our time men..
do you feel like that ha?
thanks . .
NOVIDA ISMIAZIZAH
BalasHapusXIIA6/19
Assalamu’alaikum
Hello friends,
I am Novida from pro group.
I agree with the motion"School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom". Because there are some Reasons:
1. In the SMADA, has provided various facilities and places to different activities. we certainly understand that the classroom as a place to learn, canteen to eat, and the mosque for prayers. It's useless if all the facilities are not used according to the functions.
2. have meal in the classroom can make the classroom dirty. because most students throw the rubbish (food wrappers) into a desk drawer. whereas we know that in SMADA is moving class, so nobody is solely responsible for the cleanliness class. If rubbish is left, over time will cause bad smell that can disrupt the learning process.
Thank you
good....
BalasHapusme to you
0o0
CHANDRA GUMELAR AULIA
BalasHapusXIIA6/04
hi friends
I am from the PRO GROUP
I will give my arguments based on the matter,
1. I agree, if the students should not eat in class, because in my opinion, an act that can disturb the cleanliness class. indeed, there have been a cleaning service, but it would be nice if we helped them work. anyway, it's also for the sake of students' own
2. Then, with no eating in the class, it can reduce the former junk food in the school environment. and in the cafeteria itself has place to eat and where to dispose of trash takeout,
that's my argument, thank you... :-D
RATNASARI H. HAMSAH
BalasHapusXII - IPS - II /25
Hi, Mr. Anggoro. I'm sorry for interrupting your debate but I think I can answer your questions.
first,you say that we will be more polite if we use the class as it's supposed to be. but don't you think that appreciate the teacher by do not come late to the class is more polite? let's see the fact, we can't deny that the service in our canteen is too slow to serve all of the student in senior high 2. it's always create a very long queue when the break time is come. moreover the place, can you imagine if all of students in senior high 2 lumajang have breakfast at the same time,in a small place, must be wait to get the food, and all of that must be done only in 15 minutes. how mess it will be? beside that, you say that we must manage our selves not to be hungry in the class. now what about the students who brought their own meal from home? They are trying to manage them selves not to get hungry during the lessons. by consume the meal during the break time after additional lessons in the morning IN THE CLASS. are you going to force them to go to the canteen, consume their meal there, and come back to the class? that's kind of stupidity. because it will be impossible that the teacher is angry because of our retard.
oh right and for your statement about fasting, I think we can't apply your theory because Not all of the student's are Moslem. and for the Moslem's people, before do the fasting, we have "sahur" first, and also we have motive not to eat or drink anything for more than 12 hour. if you say that the moslem must be handle their hungry like fasting, why don't you just make a rule for Moslem students to fasting everyday? so they won't abuse the class.
LOL ^_^
I agree with the statement of Hellylintarum.
BalasHapusClass is the place to learn, not to eat. if we eat in the classroom, sometimes we still do not finish our food and we love to throw it away, and often put the food under the bench, and then we forget to throw it away. And finally the food is stale and smelly, and of course it adds the work of our friends who picket. And it reduces the lesson’s time to picket. And soon, our new canteen will finish, and the place is also more wide to eat, so there is no reason to eat in the classroom because the canteen is narrow
Rolis Rohmania H
XIIA6/24
SITI FATIMATUN NAVISAH
BalasHapusXII A6/27
Hi friends,
I am Siti Fatimatun Navisah from pro group.
I agree if school does not allow students to have meal in the classroom. I will give my argument about it,
1. I think eating in the classroom makes us very uncomfortable in the class. In addition, it can make the classroom dirty, it also can make smelly classrooms. It caused by the waste generated by food wrappers.
2. If every student did not eat in the classroom, I think there will be no more junk foods that can interfere our learning in the classroom. What hurts us to the cafeteria? Just walking, and less than 5 minutes. Apart from that, we also have to use the facilities provided by schools. If we eat in the classroom, the role of the canteen will be reduced and I also do not guarantee that all students can maintain the cleanliness of the class, so I guess eating in the classroom was less effective.
That's my opinion, thank you... :)
RATNASARI H. HAMSAH
BalasHapusXII - IPS - II / 25
*additional for my comment*
Novrisa said that there is no rule that allowed the students to have meal in the classroom. but as long as I know, a rule is control something we should not do. so it's impossible for you to find a rule which is said, " you may come earlier to the school". that's really weird. but I'm sure that you know about the new rules which is said about the rule of throwing rubbish in it's place. it's implicitly said that we are allowed to have meal anywhere (including in the class), but we must throw the rubbish in the basket. problem solved! we just need to strengthen the rule and give punishment for them who throw the rubbish anywhere. it's far more better than we must do something else to "move" the students from class to the canteen. . .
Khusnul hotimah
BalasHapusXIIA6/11
Assalamualaikum,
I'm from pro group
I want to refute a statement from distania, I disagree with the provision of AC in the canteen. Because in I think, the activities in the canteen causing bad odor. So with the given AC, the unpleasant smell that cause nausea for some people.
In my opinion, school canteen isn’t crowd because of the many children who eat there. But the crowded because of the students want to buy food. And not all students purchase food in times of rest, too. So the school canteen adequate capacity, and here I also agree with the statement of Rolis that class is used for class learning activities.
NUR KHASANAH SAHIDIN
BalasHapusXIIS1 / 25
i want to argue siti fatimatun's comment about the motion "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom".
i am from contra group argues that eating in classroom will make students feel comfortable because the students will not rush when eating for fear of being late to class, the students do not need to waste a lot of energy to serried find a seat in the cafeteria, as well as our goods would be safe in the classroom .
if you say 'Just walk into the cafeteria, and less than 5 minutes' I think it's wrong. Need to remember when a XII grade tutoring in the morning, when completed will be used for breakfast for students who have not had breakfast from her home. if the students have to walk and eat in the cafeteria will likely spend more than 5 minutes and it will make the students late entry into the classroom. so the students is not allowed to take lessons for 2 X 45 minutes.
when the break when all the students eat in the cafeteria, it will make students jostle for our school canteen capacity is not too large.
so, whether the student will remain banned for eating in the classroom if the conditions our school canteen like that ?
I think the motion needs to consider and changed.
Thanks in advance.
Satriyo Ponco L XIIA6/25
BalasHapusnegative for rara
because a lot of junk food in class and grow the food scraps are thrown away inside the desk drawer. although there is picket, not every incoming class of students should picket because it would interfere with classroom teaching and learning activities. therefore, to avoid garbage in the the classroom, students should not eating in class
Surya Darma Putra XIIA6/29
BalasHapusquote from Dwi's argue:
"I think my last post not only for Naufal afif, but also for all Pro Group.
as i know 90% argument from pro's group is same."
Same for me,, over 90% of contra group comments have the same main idea,, but with different vocabulary,, lol for you too.
no offense
Surya Darma Putra XIIA6/29
BalasHapusI want to comment about what nur hasanah sahidin said earlier..
I think that if you(and your friends of course)ask the teachers for meal time they won't mind..
but if there was nobody ask for it,,,,
hmmmm,, i think it's nonsense the teacher will know it,, in fact the teachers couldn't read our mind though
Novi Tri Nugraheni
BalasHapusXIIA6/18
Hy..hy..
emm, I think I have a same opinion with khusnul and rollis, the class is used for the process of learning, if the students want to eat it can also be outside the classroom or in canteen, so there isn't waste in the classroom, and if there is garbage in the class because of the meal do you will feel comfortable and concentrate on learning while waste a lot of scattered and cause odor?
thank you
Surya Darma Putra XIIA6/29
BalasHapussame opinion with Novi Tri ^^^^^up^^^^
having meal outside the class have many advantage, one of them is if the students still throwing garbage outside the classroom,, the teachers(at least one of them)who passed thw way will see it and give them some punishment,,,
in the other hand, if the students eat inside of the class, how could we know the throw it in the proper place or not???
thank you before and after
LILIK SUCI CENDRANI
BalasHapusXII - IPS - 01 / 17
I want argue SITI FATIMATUN NAVISAH opinion ,
1. you said that if have meal in the classroom can make the classroom dirty .
But, as we know school provide a dump in every class . We can throw out the waste into the dump.
throw out the waste isn't difficult thing by our self .
I think it is easy .
So we can keep our class clean.^^
2.also, you said that if we have meal in the canteen ,we just need less than 5 minutes.
It's ok, 5 minutes ,
but we JUST ARRIVED in the canteen.
how about the time when we queue to get food?
i think it is more than 5 minutes(Remember we just have 15 minutes for break time)
in the fact , at the same time a number of students go to canteen , but the stand where provide food is limited.
so, we must queue to get the food.
after we get the food , we still not eat the food yet.
if the school does not allow have meal in the class, the students will come late to the class.
because the place in the canteen also limited.
so we must queue again to get the place.
i think it is my opinion .
thx ^^.
Surya Darma P XIIA6/29
BalasHapusfor lilik suci's argument,,
so you think that it's better if we eat buy the meal then eat it in the class???
if so,, I think it will make us spend the same time,, this is my description
go to canteen > buy meal > eat there > back to the class
and...
go to canteen > buy meal > back to the class > eat there
like I said, both of them are same..
and if(I said if), the seats in the canteen run out, we can eat meal outside the classroom right? and there is no way we will run out of seat outside the classroom because there are many of them(I mean the seats)
and you don't need to shy eat you home made meal outside the classroom, because other students will do the same thing ^^
thank you
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII S2 - 12
BalasHapus"The rubbish in the canteen isn't matter, the most important thing is there is no rubbish in the classroom. But, awareness to be clean in everywhere should be applied in our daily life."
ROFL !
The rubbish in the canteen isn't matter ?
why you said that ? can i called it QQ-er ?
one more thing:
" We have to be able to manage ourselves not to be hungry in the classroom. If we can hold our hunger for more than 12 hours in fasting month and at that time we're having learning activities,why we can't hold our hunger just for a few hours. "
so, for these 3 years you didn't eat at the canteen ? you can manage your " hunger " ?
you can hold your hungry ?
Like a " master of goody " :|
and i agree with Ratnasari post .
" oh right and for your statement about fasting, I think we can't apply your theory because Not all of the student's are Moslem. and for the Moslem's people, before do the fasting, we have "sahur" first, and also we have motive not to eat or drink anything for more than 12 hour. if you say that the moslem must be handle their hungry like fasting, why don't you just make a rule for Moslem students to fasting everyday? so they won't abuse the class. "
please, ( sorry ) don't be so selfish . If u said that, you can read my last opinion . ROFL :|
-> Surya Darma : lol. Just another "word" >.>
but, do you feel like that huh ? :3
btw, about eating in the outside class.
i don't think so.
do you mean, we eat our meal on the chair ( in front of class ) ?
let me exp something.
SMADA have +- 800 student, canteen can accommodate +- 300 - 500 ( @_@ over load )
so the rest +- 300 student, and with your argument before . we can eat in outside the class ? +- 300 student eat outside the class ? @____@
i know, not all student eat in break time. but, can you think my retarded comment ? -_-
OK. that's enough.
No more comment . Thank you @____@
:|
LAILY ZAKIAH ILMI
BalasHapusXII SAINS 6 / 12
Assalamu'laikum wr.wb.
I'm from pro group, and I'll give my argument about the motion.
I believe students should not be allowed to eat in class. I think this way for many reasons. First, if students were given the option to eat in class obesity rates would be at an all time high. For example, if the teachers were ok with students eating in class, students would always be eating, and that would cause them to gain a lot more weight vs. eating just during lunch. Secondly, I think if eating in class was allowed students’ grades would drop because all their attention would be on the food. And not what the teachers are saying or their actual work. So eating in class wouldn’t be a good idea.
Another reason students should not be allowed to digest food in class is because the students would be very sleepy and have no attention towards their work. Food tends to make you sleepy so all the kids would rather be napping instead of working/studying. Therefore to allow eating in class would be a bad idea. Lastly, many students don’t pick up after themselves so when the school allows them to eat during class, our school will be a living trash can. Allowing food in classrooms is a very awful idea.
This is from me. Thanks.
Novi Tri Nugraheni
BalasHapusXIIA6/18
For Dwi P.
Dwi, I think you are to exaggerate,,:0
have you ever seen 300 students at the canteen at the same time??
not for me,,
i think most(over the half) of the students are enjoying their break time to joke with their friends( thats what i think )
Thanks
eventhough the canteen only could contain, let we say, 400 students,, they won't come to the canteen at the same time,,
Karunia Dyah M.
BalasHapusXIIA6/10
Assalamu'alaikum Wr. Wb.
I'm from pro group.
I agree that eating shouldn't be allowed in the classroom.It is a distraction to the teaching and learning process. There are several reasons for this:
1. The smell of garbage that might left will distract for the other student,so they can't concentrate to learn .
2. Students who are eating in class might spill the food on their books or on the floor. It could cause the classroom messy and disrupt atmosphere or purpose of the lesson.
Thank you ^_^
Wassalamu'alaikum Wr. Wb.
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII S2 - 12
BalasHapus-> Novi Tri
Please read my post carefully .
" i know, not all student eat in break time. but, can you think my retarded comment ? -_- "
but, thanks for your comment.
SANDY SETYAWAN XII IPS 2 - 26
BalasHapusI just give a little addition to my friend's opinion in contra group.
i think one of the advantages of having meal in the class is we can studied some subject while we having meal in the class,this thing can make the 15 minutes of break time be more useful than we go to the canteen spending lots of cost and times ,
like the indonesian aphorism said " sambil menyelam minum air",so we can use the break time wisely if we having meal in the class, I think that's my conclusion for now...,I wait for the other's argument..,thank you.
bintang cahyaning
BalasHapusXII A 7 - 08
I'm from pro group
I agree with that motion, because it was a rule made by the school so we have to obey them.
I think eating in class was not polite. classroom is a place to learn, not to eat. eat at his place in the school cafeteria.
besides, eating in the classroom can make the classroom a dirty, because the fact of the students after a meal will dispose of their garbage in their desk drawer.
so, as a good student, then we must obey the rules made by the school that should not eat in class. it aims to maintain the cleanliness and comfort of our class in the learning process. better we eat in the cafeteria that has been provided by the school because it has guaranteed cleanliness and comfort.
EKBAR MANDALA PUTRA XII IPS 1/ 14
BalasHapusi disagree if school not allow the student to have meal in the classroom. because if student must have meal in the canteen, they waste time. we knew that the break time just fifteen minutes, and we must do the eficien thing on that time. and the most important reason is canteen can't accommodate all the student to have meal there.
and if we are late to class because eating in the canteen, it's very detrimental to us and teachers who will teach. if the teacher could not understand the problem, but when teachers could discipline we can not take lessons. so students should be allowed to eat in class to save time that there.
thank you
tio dwi wibisono
BalasHapusXII A6
I'm from pro group
I in line with that motion, because it was a rule made by the school so we have to obey them.
I think that eating in class is not supported in the program about the cleanliness of the school
because, studying the characteristics of students today who are lazy throw trash in its place
This will also be a concern of students who throw trash on the class,,, as in a desk drawer or other place in the classroom
thank you
tio dwi w
BalasHapusXII A6/30
i want to argue DWI PURNOMO's opinion
from your opinion, are you sure that bad eating habits in the classroom, does not pose the problem of waste?
when in fact until now, shows that the problem of garbage in the classroom no other reason is because they often eat in space.
thnks
Izzatul Islam XII A7 / 19
BalasHapushi friends, I agree with this motion and i have some reason :
first, bringing food into the classroom can make the classroom becomes dirty and uncomfortable. imagine if we had to learn in a place filled with leftover food and garbage scraps. Can we learn in comfort? can we? besides that the odor generated leftover food must be very disturbing our learning.
second, this prohibition is one of the business school to create waste-free atmosphere in the classroom. schools already provide advice to dump the trash and also has provided bins in every corner of the school, but in fact garbage still piling up in the classroom. if you do not agree with the motion above, can you maintain the cleanliness of the classroom and want to be responsible with rubbish that piled them?
third, the school has provided a canteen for a place to rest and eat, why we do not use this facility? many argue that the size of school cafeteria is small and is unable to accommodate all SMADA's students . schools have been trying to fix it? school has set up a new cafeteria large enough to be occupied SMADA's students. does it not satisfy us? The new canteen in the future would be more comfortable and enjoyable
and lastly, let's make our schools free from trash.and make our learning atmosphere as comfortable as possible. ! we are already the third grade, do not let garbage destroying our precious memories of smada! : D
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII S2 - 12
BalasHapus-> Novrisha Anggoro
I'm still waiting for your comment about your last post .
you can check it ->
" The rubbish in the canteen isn't matter "
what does it mean ?
i want to see our canteen in 2-4 weeks without any ppl to clean up. and of course all student MUST have his / her meal in the canteen .
is it problem ?
From your opinion, i think . It's no problem .
am i right ? Novrisha Anggoro ?
thank you :}
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII S2 - 12
BalasHapusWTH !!!
my last post for Mr. Tio didn't appear Q___Q
sorry for Mr.Tio, maybe next time :p
*i'm so lazy to typing your comment again ( 4-6 paragraph )
:3
Rendra Kurniawan / XII A7 / 27
BalasHapusI'm from pro group.,,
I agree with argument "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom". Because there are several Smada's Students that still indiscipline with the cleanliness,especially in the class. It can be proved by the numbers of garbages that appear in the class at the break time. And it brings bad influence to our study in class because the garbages produce bad smell or it can make our class dirty.
Besides that, there are several advantages to be had,if we eat at the canteen, like we can socialize with friends from other classes. And soon, the new canteen of smada will finish. i think it is enough to accomodate the students of smada,....
Thank You.....
Nandani Dwi XIIA6/15
BalasHapusI am from the pro, I agree if carrying banned food in the classroom, because I think eating in the classroom will have a negative impact
first, when a student brought food to class, they will walk from the classroom to the cafeteria and then go back to class again, then the way it rest time runs out, so eating in the cafeteria is more effective than in the classroom
plus, because the hours of rest runs out the student will usually eat idalam class time learning, so it will disrupt the learning process
then, eating in class when the lesson certainly a very bad thing because the does not respect teachers who are teaching
Finally, students who bring food into the class will throw litter, which can interfere with the beauty of the class, although not all students do that
thank you
Rendy Permana XIIA6 / 23
BalasHapuspositive for all of my pro arguments..
first of all,, don't you ever think what has made the classroom so dirty??
GARBAGE, is the answer,, then, where is it come from??
of course from those students who having meal in the classroom and didn't think about the bad habit,,
so,, I'm really pro if the school prohibit the students having their meal in the classroom
thank you
IQBAL AGUNG BUDI SANTOSO / XII S1 / 16
BalasHapusI'm from contra group.
I disagree with is not allowed students to carry or eat food in the classroom. because we already know that students in grade 12 following additional lessons every morning. students are required to come at 5:30, with a schedule like that students do not go to breakfast at home, especially students who have a home away from schools and students living in boarding house. so students are bringing lunch to eat at school or buy food at school canteen, unfortunately the time allowed for students to rest and breakfast was minimal. so the students do not have much time to go to the canteen that has a considerable distance. so the students decided to have breakfast in the classroom.
so it should students be allowed to eat in the classroom but on condition that students must maintain the cleanliness of the classroom.
AVISA PERMATASARI
BalasHapusXII A7/07
I want to convey the group of pro argument agree that bringing or eating in class is problem. Because:
1. will make our classrooms like dirty trash. where waste from the packs of food or drink we usually throw in a desk drawer or on the floor. And may we learn in the trash like the TPS? When we had the intention of going home to smada to seek knowledge, but we end with a question in class dirt. Certainly smell and presence of garbage disrupts our learning activities.
2. although students are allowed to bring food to the rules in class but should be disposed of waste in place, in fact, there is also a discard class. This proves that there are students who are not disciplined. And right when the school gave a stern warning prohibiting carrying food in the classroom.
3. Smada must be clean. And we know Smada also are building a new cafeteria for us. Smada we as citizens must help support and maintain the condition of the classroom and the cafeteria, by not littering.
So, a ban on bringing food in the classroom can make us disciplined than other schools because it is R-SBI smada .. hhe
MUHAMMAD RIZKI HIDAYAT XII A 6 / 14
BalasHapusI am from pro group, of course I agree about the motion. Because I think eating in the classroom can interfere with school hours. Why? we know from eating in class, class consequently become dirty. Despite the fact that the class becomes dirty, the students did not want to clean up the class without any command from the teacher. So that teachers want to teach, the learning time is cut to clean the classroom.
It's my opinion about the motion.
Thanks.
Diva Addini Maghribi Muyassiroh
BalasHapusXIIA6/05
Assalamualaikum wr. wb.
I'm from the pro group
I want to argue
I am in line with the opinion of the "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom".
I have several reasons why I support this opinion.
First, if students are not allowed to bring food into the classroom, the class will be free of waste generated from the food which we bring into the classroom. We know if a lot of junk in the class, then we will also feel uncomfortable when we get lessons. In addition, if the class is dirty and a lot of garbage, especially in a desk drawer, then our teachers would usually tell us to clean it up and throw it away. This will cause our learning time will be reduced only to dispose of trash.
Second, when we eat in the canteen and we forgot to remove the pack from our food, we don’t worry because there is still a canteen worker who will clean it up. But if we forget to throw it when we eat in the class, then “who is going to throw it away?” The cleaner? , Maybe they'll just clean the outside of the classroom, not until into the classroom. Other students? It can happen if they care, was told by the teacher, or when the odor was smelled and had been bothering them while they learn.
Third, if the future regulation of "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom" is applied, then this will be good not only for us but also for the environment. why, because the use of food packs will be reduced. so that, the production of the wrap food waste will also be reduced.
That's just my opinion.
thank you
Wassalamualaikum wr. wb.
tio dwi w XII A6/30
BalasHapusiam contradict with mr. dwi purnomo handono
.
it's all just an excuse!!
try talking with your mouth or with your foot!
IMANIAR NUNGKY KAUTSAR
BalasHapusXII A6/09
I am from the pro group.
I agree with the opinion of the "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom".
Because it's make some problem like make class dirty(1),and then if the class is dirty the student can't concentration to the lesson and the teacher is also will lazy to teach the student because they fell uncomfortable with the class condition(2).
Beside that the dirty class is also will make bacteria gathered into one and in long time it's cause disease(3).
That's my opinion...if YOU WANT ARGUE it...i will say Thank you because you was make attention in my Coment....."CAO"
.....see you in real life.....
APRILIA KUSUMAWARDANI
BalasHapusXIIA7/05
.
Asslamu'alaikum
I agree with the argument "that most of the garbage in the classroom comes from takeout brought by students into the classroom and it makes a bad habit for students sma 2 Lumajang own.
I argue, If we eat in the classroom , many other activities that we do besides eat. and it gives a negative effect on our own bodies, such as when eat and read lessons in the class, while browsing the Internet, and eat hidden when the teacher explained, This certainly gives a bad effect for us, when our attention was distracted, we tend to eat more than we need and we do not control what entered into our mouths.
According to various studies, eating while doing other activities can cause a lack of satisfaction with the food consumed. As a result, you are encouraged to eat more. The solution is simple: focus with our food while eating, and should do on the cafeteria table that does not involve a lot of other activities besides eating.
AKHMAD RIDHO
BalasHapusXIIA7/03
Assalamualiakum
for the first,i think this problem is not too complicated.cause we knew that our school had many points of rules that forbidded us to littering the trush in some places, especially in the classroom.and we must try to obey the rules if we wanna be a good student,isn't?thanks
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII S2 - 12
BalasHapus-> Tio
calm down man. cooling down pls . you are too QQ in this discussion . lol
ROFL BABY ! RTD your mind !
STFU Tio, and read this post ! LMFAO !!!
FIRST !
Try to study typing / reading .
1. My name Dwi Purnama Handoko. your 1st post said : DWI PURNOMO . and your 2nd post said : dwi purnomo handono .
wajajajaja ! ROFL ! Q_Q more ! wahahaha .
OK !
Let me talk with my foot . :}
" I think that eating in class is not supported in the program about the cleanliness of the school
because, studying the characteristics of students today who are lazy throw trash in its place "
-> students today who are lazy throw trash in its place .
So, from this simple word. Pls, when we have break time, and you go to canteen. look ! the student have meal right ? but, what about the rubbish ? they put their rubbish in the dustbin ? are you sure ? No, of course. why ? wanna some little prove ? CTO !
www*DOT*mediafire*DOT*com/download.php?qaouf77uvopgq83
www*DOT*mediafire*DOT*com/download.php?99yvn1nfjkex0xu
wooow, what's that ? @_@
some student put the rubbish in the dustbin ?
NAY ! student still ignoring their rubbish .
So, Mr. Tio what the difference between we have meal in the class, make our class dirty *your opinion of course* and we have meal in canteen, and make our canteen dirty ?
ah yes, one more important think.
From -> Novrisha Anggoro
" The rubbish in the canteen isn't matter "
do you agree with her opinion ? or do you disagree ?
you're too Q_Q man.
It's just simple discussion for our test.
your last post like you have been Q_Q-ing in this discussion. so, calm down and refresh your mind.
enough ? or do you want more exp ?
slow, we have +- 42 hours to make some Q_Q to you . :))
AKHMAD RIDHO
BalasHapusXIIA7/03
to dwi purnomo handoko
I didn't agree with your opinion,cause i think that our canteen has big capacity.and you must know that if you try to compared it with the totally quantity of the students(about 800 students) it's a wrong idea.in a fact,we knew maybe rather 80% of totally students wanna choose to eat their meal in the canteen.so,there is no reason to violate the rules guys....!
AKHMAD RIDHO
BalasHapusXIIA7/03
furthermore,we knew that our earth is in critical condition,if we should try to obey our school rules,maybe we can got many positive thing.like a good respiration factor for our life.so,start from now,we must familiarize ourself to not eat the meal inside the class that it can increase the impact of many disease such as thypus etc.
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII S2 - 12
BalasHapusOne more ppl said wrong name. lol
ok, np .
but, for Mr. Akhmad Ridho
before i comment you post.
i would say this : Please read my other post carefully .
you can check this , ctrl + f :
" i know, not all student eat in break time. but, can you think my retarded comment ? -_- "
ok ?
from another XII grade in SMADA
BalasHapusvery good assignment, applause for mr.tris, because of your great learning way through technology, especially internet, so the student not only use internet for entertainment media, but also for learn process(submit a task)
maju terus SMADA Lumajang!!!
Fitri Hajar Rofiqoh (XII-A7/16)
BalasHapus1. in Indonesia eat in the classroom is considered to be something unnatural. ate in the classroom is a culture that is not good and it is not polite.
2.classroom is a place to learn, not to eat. after all, every school must also provide the canteen so that students can eat there. class is not the appropriate place to eat because the class only serves as a teaching and learning activities.
3.usually for students who do not have a sense of responsibility, they often throw food wrap in the locker. it would damage the cleanliness class and dirty creating an uncomfortable atmosphere for learning. to avoid this, each student should not eat in the classroom, especially when to discard food wrappers in the locker table.
I strongly agree that students are forbidden to bring food to class because it raises a lot of negativity and culture do not bring food in the classroom has become a culture of most schools in Indonesia.
INDAH PURNAMASARI
BalasHapus(XIIA7/17)
I'm from pro group, and I'll give my argument about the motion.
1. with have meal in canteen, we can excercise our dicipline, because canteen is the right place to have some meal,
why excercise dicipline? because when we have some meal in canteen, we can dicipline our time, whether we must continue to eat or must stop it.
2. have meal in canteen, we will get near to another food, so if we want to buy another food, we just walk a few meters and easily buy it.
3. when we have meal in class, student of smada are spread in all room in smada, so if we forget to put the rubbish into dustbin, the rubbish will spread in all of the room in smada.
but if we have meal in canteen, although we forget to put the rubbish into the dustbin (and only put the rubbish on the canteen's table, the rubbish will be easily collected.
so, smada student are better having some meal in canteen.
to :IQBAL AGUNG BUDI SANTOSO / XII S1 / 16
BalasHapusfrom : Fitri H.R. XII-A7/16
as a smart student, you certainly need to know about it. however, the canteen is a place to eat, although the walk to the canteen waste of time, but if you have the consistency, you should be able to conduct activities in accordance place. according to you, whether it is feasible if the class that should be used as a place of learning is used as a place to eat?
I do not think like that. for what the school canteen building if it turns out students instead use a class to eat?
class to learn and eating place was the canteen. you should be able to difference two things.
Nike Nurjannah (XIIA6/17)
BalasHapusassalamualaikum..
I'm in pro group.
I agree with all of arguments from pro group.
I think school should not allowed students have meal in class because have meal in the class is not polite and it make the students have bad habit. classrom is not a place to have meal, we have a canteen so why we can't enjoy our meal in canteen? then, I think have meal in the class make the students throw the rubbish in there, so it make the classroom dirty. it make other students feel not comfortable when they study in there. and the last, I think to make the classroom clean because of the all rubbish, we waste our time.. we must sweep and clean the room in the study hours and it make the time not efective.. that's why i'm agree if school not allowed the students have meal in the class.. if I make the wrong words, please forgive me.. thank you...
Lukita Qirotul Ayunin (XIIA6/13)
BalasHapusasslamualikum...
I'm in same line with Nike, I think the students should not have meal in the class, because class in not place to have meal.. but maybe the students think that have meal in the class is efective because they don't need much time to go canteen and go back to the class when the break time end. I'm agree if school should not allow the students have meal in the class, but school must have the place where the students can enjoy their meal. canteen is not big enough to them.. we have about 900 students in our school, it's imposible if they have meal in the canteen in the same time... certainly, it's make them not comfortable to have meal in the canteen...
Nandani Dwi O. (XIIA6/15)
BalasHapusassalamualaikum Wr Wb
I'm from pro group.I agree about bringing food into the class is forbidden.I think that eating in the class causes more disadvantages than advantages. Some disadvantages are :
1. If the students bring food into the class,they will walk from the class to the canteen and go back to the class again.In that journey ,the rest time will be up .So,eating in the canteen is more effective than eating in the class
2.That the rest time will be up usually makes the students eat food in the class when the
lesson is in progress.Finally,the students can't pay attention to the lesson .So study process will be disturbed.
3. eating food in the class when the lesson is in prosress is a bad habit because it's the same with the students dont respect the teacher who is teaching them
4.the students who bring food into the class usually will throw the rubbish in some parts of the class.It can decrease the cleaness of the class.
so, based on some reason above,I really agree that the school does not allowed the studens bring food into the class.Thank you
wassalamualaikum Wr Wb
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII S2 - 12
BalasHapus-> Lukita
so, what's your point ?
because i can't get your point.
i have 2 reason :
1. you said : " I think the students should not have meal in the class, because class in not place to have meal "
ok, from this. i think you disagree when student have meal in the classroom . am i right ?
2. " it's imposible if they have meal in the canteen in the same time... certainly, it's make them not comfortable to have meal in the canteen "
from this post, ( Correct me if i'm wrong ) . In other word, you have problem when our canteen "over load" .
So, what's the exactly your point ?
sorry before, and thank you (",)~
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII S2 - 12
BalasHapus-> AKHMAD RIDHO
" furthermore,we knew that our earth is in critical condition,if we should try to obey our school rules,maybe we can got many positive thing.like a good respiration factor for our life.so,start from now,we must familiarize ourself to not eat the meal inside the class that it can increase the impact of many disease such as thypus etc "
Before you said that .
Please, look my SS before.
u can find it : ctrl+f : mediafire
So, u can make another point .
because, from my SS. no difference between rubbish in the class / rubbish in the canteen .
Thanks (",)~
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII S2 - 12
BalasHapusPS For Mr. Akhmad Ridho
From Novrisha Anggoro
" The rubbish in the canteen isn't matter "
So, nope we put / throw our rubbish in the canteen .
lol :)
and, what about with your opinion before :
" earth is in critical condition,if we should try to obey our school rules,maybe we can got many positive thing.like a good respiration factor for our life.so,start from now,we must familiarize ourself to not eat the meal inside the class that it can increase the impact of many disease such as thypus etc "
i'm combine your post & Novrisha's post .
From Novrisha, it isn't matter when our canteen dirty. and from your post " we must familiarize ourself to not eat the meal inside the class that it can increase the impact of many disease such as thypus etc "
can you get my point Mr. Akhmad Ridho ?
Thank you (",)~
Adam Taruna Kusuma (XIIA7/01)
BalasHapusI think the rule from the school that say the students should not to have meal in the class is a right rule.If the students have meal in the class,so what's the different between class and canteen. that rule has a function to give the different between class and canteen.
i'm on nike's argument, if students having meal in the class, some of they will throw the waste under the table. some teacher usually ask us to clean under the table, is decrease our study time. the impact of this, the materials is not fully sent to us.
BalasHapuspandu
BalasHapusXIIA6/20
i'm on nike's argument, if students having meal in the class, some of they will throw the waste under the table. some teacher usually ask us to clean under the table, is decrease our study time. the impact of this, the materials is not fully sent to us.
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII S2 - 12
BalasHapus-> Adam Taruna Kusuma
" If the students have meal in the class,so what's the different between class and canteen. that rule has a function to give the different between class and canteen. "
and i want to ask some simple question to you .
what's the difference between student put their rubbish in canteen and student put their rubbish in their table / in the classroom. any difference ? mention it, i want to know it.
Thanks
Ariek Prihandini (08)
BalasHapusXII-ips 2
It can be solved if we school supply rubbish box in the class.... and make a ruler who throw rubbish everywhere will get punishment.....
Raditya Eka Oktarina
BalasHapusXII.A6
21
It's my opinion on the School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom
1. To maintain the cleanliness class
Often there is a warning about the cleanliness of the environment, for example, the school environment clean. For that we can start by maintaining cleanliness within the scope of the smallest in our school environment that is class. I agree with the rules of the School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom. Given these rules we can improve environmental hygiene in our schools, because it can reduce the rubbish that is left is in a class of food that was brought and eaten in the classroom. So it can create a clean school environment.
2. Utilization of functional canteen
Canteen is a room in a public building that can be used for dining patrons. For that a canteen was built at the school students as a place to eat, so if we eat our food in the classroom so we can not utilize the functionality of existing canteen to the fullest. Also when we eat in the cafeteria we will get a different atmosphere when eating in class, namely the atmosphere of togetherness with our friends of different classes.
3. time efficiency
More quickly when we eat our food in the canteen directly
MUCHAMAD REZA ISMAWAN XII-S1
BalasHapuswow debate has already begun
if no one asks seem to trite
so in here I will ask to all. what you do or think if the rules are a reality that brings food to the class that prohibited? and there are sanctions for violations of which will be issued at the time of the class lessons
thank's
SITI FATIMATUN NAVISAH
BalasHapusXII A6/27
I would like to respond Lilik Suci Cendrani’s comment.
1. Ok. Maybe you could do that, throw garbage in its place. But, do you can guarantee all students in our schools can throw the garbage in its place? Every ceremony, our teachers always reminds us about the garbage, but is the amount of garbage that littered in the class diminished? I do not think so.
2. I have to say that “go” to the canteen was no more than 5 minutes. Five minutes for go to the canteen, five minutes for eating there, and five minutes for come back to the class. I think 15 minutes are enough to go to the canteen. Unless, we are still mostly talking with our friend in the canteen, it is likely to be late and get yelled teachers in the class.
3. Therefore, we must return to the main purpose we went to the canteen, which is eating. After that we return to the classroom. I also think, that not all students are going to the canteen, so I guess it's not a reason for us to not to eat there.
That’s all my responses. Thank you for your comments on my arguments. :)
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII S2 - 12
BalasHapus-> SITI FATIMATUN NAVISAH
Sorry before. but i want to ask something .
" 1. Ok. Maybe you could do that, throw garbage in its place. But, do you can guarantee all students in our schools can throw the garbage in its place? "
So, all student who have meal in the canteen put their rubbish in the dustbin ? i would say : no .
and, what's the difference with we have meal in the class ? make our canteen dirty .
in Novrisha's opinion it is no problem when our canteen dirty . ( check from her post )
but, when we have meal in the class, we ( +- 50 -70% ) would put our rubbish in the dustbin outside each classroom.
The only One reason to student put their rubbish in the class MAYBE, when they have meal suddenly the teacher come, and they put their rubbish in the under the table ( which is will be thrown away after the lesson finish ), but they forget about their rubbish :}
i don't mind, we have meal and we always put the rubbish in the under table. Maybe the one reason is my opinion before .
maybe that's all. sorry before @_@
Aprilia Dwi Anggraeni
BalasHapusXIIA6-2
Assalamualaikum..wr..wb
I think there is also a good idea if students are not allowed to bring food into the classroom. No other reason because of cleanliness. We know that cleanliness is currently rare in the classroom, this is due to students who like littering, especially in a desk drawer. Supposedly, the students AWARE and BE RESPONSIBLE for having allowed to bring food in the classroom. But, it seems that students are increasingly indifferent to their own waste generated. So then, why not just students spend their food in the canteen if in the end it will pollute the class??
>>In addition, I agree with Siti Fatimatun’s responses to LILIK SUCI C.XIIS1. that Lilik could throw garbage in its place,but another is not possible. So, better in the cafeteria alone and
cleanliness of the class will be maintained. And the teacher will not painstakingly remind students to clean up the garbage before the start of the lesson because it is not very effective in my opinion..
thanks..
Abdul Haris Prismbodo
BalasHapusXII S2
Hello friends
I'am Haris, i'am from contra group. I think the motion of forbid student to est the food in the class is non sense. Because a canteen can not provider place for student to eat so the student can eat their food in the class. It is more comfortable. That's All my opinion
Abdul Haris Priambodo
BalasHapusXII S2 / 01
Hello friends
I'am Haris, i'am from contra group. I think the motion of forbid student to est the food in the class is non sense. Because a canteen can not provider place for student to eat so the student can eat their food in the class. It is more comfortable. That's All my opinion
Cici Suci Maulina
BalasHapusXII IPA 7-09
assalamualaikum WR.WB
hmm, i think "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom" is good program for SMAN 02 LUMAJANG's student. i think like that based of some reason and fact.
1. "not allow students to have meal in the classroom" , because our school have a canteen yet, so what is the function of canteen if in the end all of student eat their food in the class? so, we must go to canteen and eat in there, NOT IN THE CLASS!
2. "not allow students to have meal in the classroom", because in the fact many of student that bring their food in the class, always lazy to throw the rubbis/ the plastic of their food in to the correct place for rubbish,and often they put the rubbish under table, so the class become very dirty . and in the end, we can not concentration with our lesson because the codition of our class is dirty. so the finally, it can decrease our spirit to study more in the class.
3. beside that, if many rubbish in the class or dirty, it means that we wont follow the order of Allah in order that "keep clean". REMEMBER! cleanliness is part of our believe......
soo.... bring meal in to the class must be prohibited!!
Wassalamualaikum WR.WB
AKHMAD RIDHO
BalasHapusXIIA7/03
TO dwi purnama handoko
i know what do you mean grandpa dwi...hahaha
but,we must had a truth to do something little like,obey the rules from our school,especially respect to the our class condition.you must know,recently many impact had produced by the trush.moreover,if you do the stupid thing like throw or hide the rubbish into the class.keep in mind that a good.not only classroom that we could placed to eat our meal.but we could do it in many part of our school like canteen or gazebo maybe...
AKHMAD RIDHO
BalasHapusXIIA7/03
to dwi purnama handoko
sorry,before i argue your opinion,i have a simple question for you.did you lie about "but, when we have meal in the class, we ( +- 50 -70% ) would put our rubbish in the dustbin outside each classroom"(your effort argument)??are you blind?cause in fact i knew that all of the students usually put their rubbish into the inside of the classroom.it can very disturb for our study time.cause it smell bad and seldom i find a rotten food in the plastic rubbish like,rice or breads.
DINDA ANGGERINDA SARI
BalasHapusXII S 1 / 09
Hello friends. . .
I am from a contra group,
not agree that the school does not allow students to eat in the classroom, because I have some opinions:
1. canteen at SMAN 2 Lumajang can not accommodate all students in SMADA, because the number of students are not comparable to the canteen area.
2. students who are in the classroom and away from the canteen, did not have enough time to walk towards the canteen.
3. time off only 15 minutes, limiting the students who will eat in the cafeteria, as inedible by the time to run.
thanks, that's my opinion ^ ^
> Izzatul Islam XII A 7
BalasHapusI disagree with your opinion, because eating in class does not always produce garbage, students can also bring a lunch, without the produce waste.
and also, if the students buy a pack of rice, they also can dispose of their garbage trash place that has been provided.
so, eat in class does not always produce garbage.
depending on how the personality of the student, to address this.
Thank you.
DINDA ANGGERINDA SARI/ XII S 1/ 09
BalasHapus> Izzatul Islam XII A 7
I disagree with your opinion, because eating in class does not always produce garbage, students can also bring a lunch, without the produce waste.
and also, if the students buy a pack of rice, they also can dispose of their garbage trash place that has been provided.
so, eat in class does not always produce garbage.
depending on how the personality of the student, to address this.
Thank you.
Chandra Gumelar Aulia XIIA6 / 04
BalasHapusI want to add a statement of Lukita ...
I think, if schools do not allow students to eat in the classroom, the school should be able to find a solution to resolve the issue.
for example, adds its own special place to eat and drink that could accommodate all the citizens of the school, or whatever ...
And now, the school has built a new cafeteria is bigger than the old canteen, although still in the process of work.
with the canteen, , it might help solve that problem.
it's just my opinion of ... thanks :-)
Intan Putri Natari XII-A7/18
BalasHapusadding some statements that pro group suppose to give,,
do contra group realize that our teacher always remind us to keep clean in everywhere, maybe in the class or many places in senior high school 2 lumajang,,they said that they didn't bore with that but keep remind about something that has same condition make us bored too. So you guys didn't throw the rubbish correctly. the teacher won't remind us if we do something good. but you know that our teacher always say that you must keep clean, which mean that we are do something bad about clean. many teacher in ceremony said that the classes are very dirty because of food, it means that bring food to class is bad habbit.
thanks :D
DINDA ANGGERINDA SARI/ XII S 1/ 09
BalasHapus> Izzatul Islam XII A 7
I disagree with your opinion, because eating in class does not always produce garbage, students can also bring a lunch, without the produce waste.
and also, if the students buy a pack of rice, they also can dispose of their garbage trash place that has been provided.
so, eat in class does not always produce garbage.
depending on how the personality of the student, to address this.
Thank you.
I want to comment that statement,
you say that eating in the class doesn't always produce garbage, but depends on the personality of the student,, we know that students have many personalities, will you able to control that? in fact that personality is special thing that human have. so how you gonna make that personality wants to throw the rubbish in the garbage?
thanks ^^
MUHAMMAD RIZKI HIDAYAT XII A 6 /14
BalasHapusI would like to respond to the opinion of dinda anggerinda sari XII S 1 number three.
You stated that the break is only 15 minutes to limit the students who will eat in the canteen. The proof, although the rest are just 15 minutes did not restrict me to eat in the canteen. But it was more than enough, because at the time I have eaten in the canteen, I went back to class on time without any lag subjects.
But I think, rest time you not only to eat, perhaps to something else. for example: do homework or assignment, etc..
Do you own a "maybe" can not set the time.
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII S2 - 12
BalasHapus-> Akhmad Ridho
Hey, i called you Mr. Akhmad Ridho for respecting symbol Q_Q
" i have a simple question for you.did you lie about "but, when we have meal in the class, we ( +- 50 -70% ) would put our rubbish in the dustbin outside each classroom"(your effort argument)??are you blind?cause in fact i knew that all of the students usually put their rubbish into the inside of the classroom.it can very disturb for our study time.cause it smell bad and seldom i find a rotten food in the plastic rubbish like,rice or breads. "
ok, let me exp this .
" are you blind?cause in fact i knew that all of the students usually put their rubbish into the inside of the classroom "
are you really said like that ? ( sorry for caps :3 ) ALL OF THE STUDENTS usually put their rubbish bla" ?
Check it once again. :3
and, i want to ask a simple question.
open your eyes and check my SS from mediafire.
did all student who have meal put their rubbish in the dustbin ?
so, from your point .
" what's the best for your mind. we have meal in the class ( and maybe make some dirty from your side of course ), or we have meal in the canteen with our rubbish in the canteen ?
we have meal in the canteen, and none clean up the canteen ( canteen isn't matter when dirty *Novrisha's post ), until several weeks ! so, do you want to buy / eat in the canteen ?
:D
OK ALL !
I'M PASS !
I'm tired :| , because all of you bullying me Q_Q . lol :D
sorry for any mistake / offense / etc .
Thank you all . BB . Have Fun :)
I'M Pass .
I'm FREEE , FREEE @_____@
Dwi Purnama Handoko XII S2 - 12
BalasHapusLast post :3
Chandra Gumelar Aulia << STFU chan :p
MUHAMMAD RIZKI HIDAYAT XII A 6 / 14
BalasHapusFor EKBAR MANDALA PUTRA XII IPS 1/ 14
What do you mean "we have efficient at doing things at rest" is to do homework?
Ratih Iza Putri N
BalasHapusXIIA6_22
Assalamu'alaikum wr.wb
I am from the pro
I agree with the opinion that the school does not allow students to eat in class.
This is because the awareness of students to maintain the cleanliness of the current decline. Although teachers have given warning to always keep it clean but they still do not care.
Waste from the food which they bring to the classroom, they threw in a desk drawer. So create a class to be dirty and cause unpleasant smell. This is very disturbing situation in the learning process in class. Therefore I agree with the opinion that the school does not allow students to eat in class and students should eat their meals in the cafeteria or outside the classroom is not in the classroom.
Trim's
Aam Taruna Kusuma (XIIA7/01)
BalasHapus->Dwi Purnama Handoko
ok,I get U'r point, but do you know the theme in this debt? it's abaut having meal in the class bro,it's not abaut put the rubbish in the class or in the canteen,,,so please debt in that theme,not in the other theme
I'm FEBI AUDI RAMADHANI XIIA7/15
BalasHapusheeei friends!!
Askummm....
i'm from pro group, and i will give some opinion for the motion
saya pikir School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom"
karena :
1. akan banyak sampah yang terkumpul didalam kelas, sedangkan. banyak sebagian siswa yang tidak membuang sampah di tempat sampah, hal itu menyebabkan kebersihan sekolah akan terganggu .dan kondisi belajar mengajar akan tidak nyaman, dan faktanya, banyak siswa yang malas keluar kelas untuk membuang sampah. jadi mereka cenderung membuang sampah dibawah laci meja.
2. Tidak sopan rasanya kita untuk 'Makan di kelas' lebih baik kita makan di canteen. jika waktu pelajaran kita sudah merasa lapar, kita mencoba untuk menahan rasa lapar selama beberapa menit saja.
oleh sebab itu, mengapa kita tidak memanfaatkan kantin sebagai tempat yang pantas utnuk kita makan. selain tempat yang pas, tempat sampah juga mudah dijangkau. jadi tak perlu malas untuk membuang sampah. dan jangan pakai alasan 'MALAS' untuk membuang sampah, demi kebersihan sekolah kita. :D
thanks friends!!
Semlikum..
I'm Febi AUDI Ramadhani XIIA7/15
BalasHapusheeei friends!!
Askummm ....
I'm from the pros group, and i will give some opinion for the motion
I think the School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom "
because:
1. will be a lot of waste collected in the classroom, while. much some students who do not throw garbage in the trash, it causes the cleanliness of the school will be disrupted. and the conditions of teaching and learning will be uncomfortable, and in fact, many students are reluctant to get out of class to the trash. so they tend to dispose of trash under the desk drawer.
2. It's not polite we are to 'Eating in class' better we eat at Canteen. if the lessons we're feeling hungry, we try to restrain your hunger for a few minutes.
therefore, why we do not use the canteen as a decent place to eat separately. in addition to the right place, the trash is also within easy reach. so no need to lazy to dispose of garbage. and do not use the excuse 'LAZY' to dispose of garbage, for the sake of cleanliness of our school. : D
thanks friends!!
Semlikum ..
Adam Taruna Kusuma (XIIA7/01)
BalasHapuslet me to argue Dwi Purnama Handoko's statement. I think all of u'r opinion in this debt are not focus in this theme,,this debt is abaut having meal bro,,but u always say abaut rubbish with many person, I think u must read again the tiltle in this debt
DEFI INDAH PRATIWI XII-A7/10
BalasHapusI'm from pro group.
I agree that students must be forbidden to have meal in class. I have so many reason to support that statement.
first reason is class in only room for study not for have meal. Have meal in class can disturb the student's concentration. It cause some students are to lazy to put their wrapper food into the dustbin. so, some of them will put the garbage into desk. then, finally the class will dirty. and that condition was exactly disturb their concentration.
second reason is school has exactly some facilities. on of them is canteen. we must use the room appropriate with its function canteen is the room for break time and having meal. and class is the study room. beside that we can keep the class clean from the wrapper food garbage.
third reason is we can reduce the plastic bags if we having meal in canteen, not in the class. we can borrow our food with our hands. but if we having meal in canteen we need plastic bags to borrow it. so, having meal in canteen can reduce the plastic waste from plastic bags.
VINDA NAFILATUZ ZAHRO
BalasHapusXII A6/ 32
Assalamu'alaikum.I'm from pro group.I think, I agree with all the arguments of the pro group.And I would add, that the School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom because the classroom in addition to causing dirty, and often occurs event clean-up class before school, also because it can reduces the sense of discipline the students to put something in it's place.we know that the class is used for learning, and the cafeteria used to have meal.
Thank's ^ ^
Wassalamu'alaikum ..
TESAR ANTONIO A. XII A7/30
BalasHapusHello guys,,,
I'm from pro group.
I agree that school doesn't allow students to have meal in the classroom, because in the SMADA there are canteen and we must get benefit from canteen with eat in the canteen and if the students have meal in the classroom certainly they are lazy to throw the rubbish on the dustbin, so they make the class dirty and can disturb the lesson.
DITA TRI
BalasHapusXII IPA 7 - 11
I agree if you are not allowed to eat in the classroom because it is a bad habit and disrespectful, especially when the lesson. class is not a place to eat. we have a canteen, why not just eat in the cafeteria?
I also think that the smell of food that can interfere with other friends who lapr and also disturb people who do not like the food.
therefore, why do not we just maakn in the cafeteria?
if in kantintidak will disturb anyone. we can also eat as much.
that is why I agree that the school prohibits students eat in the classroom.
thank you.
TESAR ANTONIO A. XII A7/30
BalasHapusI'm disagree with DINDA ANGGERINDA SARI, you think "canteen at SMAN 2 Lumajang can not accommodate all students in SMADA, because the number of students are not comparable to the canteen area", Not all students in SMADA eat in the canteen and not necessarily everyday in centeen full, and then after the students eat, they leave the canteen and we can alternately to eat.
thank you.
anggi nurvianti p.
BalasHapusXII IPA 7 - 04
I agree that the school prohibits students eat in the classroom. I have a couple of reasons,
The first, eat in the classroom is a bad habit because it will disrupt lessons causes lack of concentration of the material described by the teacher. otherwise it is not polite to eat in the classroom during a lesson because we ate hidden from the teacher so that if anyone found out we will be in the cap is not polite.
second, spilled food and wrap in a drawer and the floor was dirty and messy class cause so uncomfortable. futile if we clean up the class finally dirty and messy. therefore, we should eat in the cafeteria, do not be brought into the classroom. we can eat as much to fill in the cafeteria without having to hide from the teacher. so that the class stays clean and comfortable.
That's my opinion, thanks
edwin gene herwanto
BalasHapusXII IPS2-13
I disagree that the school prohibit student eat in the classroom. Because I think if we study with eat some food, we can get more concentration of the material described by the teacher.
Thank's
DEFI INDAH PRATIWI
BalasHapus(XIIA7/10)
The last reason is altitude Some student who was called "unpolite" sometimes will eat their food's which bought when the breaks time in lesson time. and they will eat that food when the teacher was teaching.This problem was exactly bad habits and we must avoiding it with thist rule
hello, i'm DZAI DZUL ZAKARIA XIIA7/13
BalasHapusI agree with the motion about having meal in the class is forbidden, i have many reason to support it. the first reason and most important is cleaness. if the students allow to having meal in the class they may make the class more dirty. there are many rubbishes from food wrap like plastic, paper, can, etc that were brought by students to the class. we can imagine how if all students in the class bring and having meal in the class and they are not care about the class. the second one, all the school in everywhere are have canteen to having meal for students. canteen is the right place to having meal not in the class. we can buy and directly eat the food there. and in the canteen the food is not wrapped so the risk about clean that causes by food wrap can be decrease. and the third opinion, if we student having meal in the class it can make them unfocus to the lesson in the class.
siti khadijatul qubraa
BalasHapusXIIS2_28
Hello every body..
I’m idja from the contra group.
I do not agree if the school forbids students to bring food into the classroom because for class XII students are tutoring activities besides the morning after the morning tutoring class XII mostly children use it for breakfast.
if students do not bring food from home, students will get to the canteen to buy food that has been available in the canteen, but time is needed for a long time, thus making the students to go to class late so if not allowed to bring food into the classroom will result in losses, to the students.
Also if you see the size of the cafeteria which is not too great if all students must eat in the cafeteria would not fit because of size, capacity is small. Even make the students will be doubts about the urge to buy food and drink that has been available in the canteen
So in my opinion, should the school did not forbid the students to eat in class because at the time had not long after the morning lessons.
I think that's my opinion..
Thanks :)
WISNU ADHI P. XII A7/31
BalasHapusAssalamu'alaikum
i agree that eat in the classroom must prohibited. many reason that eat in the class must prohibited.
1. we have paid to school very expensive. and the money used to build the canteen. so we must used canteen if we won't loss
2. we will pollute the classroom with rubish from eat in the classroom. so it will disturb learning in the classroom
3. we can disturb fasting person. Should those who go to the canteen?
PANJI PRAKOSO
BalasHapusXII A7/25
hello guys
I'm from pro group
I agree with the motion that the school doesn't allow students to eat in class.
first, I think eating in class time will interfere with the learning process. junk in a drawer and the dirty floor make a mess of classroom and caused great discomfort. of course it's not cool, isn't it? surely you will not like the atmosphere like that.
second, we could interfere with our own friends, perhaps those who are fasting and it is impossible for them to go to the cafeteria. Did they should go to the canteen?
third, third, SMAN 2 Lumajang canteen are now built a larger, I think is now able to accommodate more students who want to eat in the cafeteria
Izzatul Islam XII A7 / 19
BalasHapusI respond to dinda's statement .indeed not all foods can lead to accumulated trash, but in fact the garbage from food remains strewn in the classroom .isnt it?
also you know,with the existence of this prohibition, we can minimize the waste that is in class and can separate the types of garbage. waste food scraps can we separate them with paper waste can be recycled. This also is a concern we can maintain the environment well. besides, this is our application form to apply the PLH lessons we have ever learned in second grade....
:)
RIAN ADIPUTRA P. 28/XIIA7
BalasHapusassalamualaikum wr. wb.
god bless you all...
i'm on pro-group agree with the motion "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom".
in my opinion classroom is the place of student get theory lesson and student must be enjoy with the condition. we'ill be enjoy to study if the classroom clean, cool and fresh.if you have meal in the class i guess you'ill be reluctant to throw the food pack to the rubbish bin and put the garbage under table. the clean school guard impossible to enter the classroom at the lesson begin just for clean the rubbish under table.
and if you eat meal that have strong smells like sambel trasi or pete, it must be disturb other students
i suggest you to eat in canteen because canteen is the right place to you having meal because in there the canteen guard always standby to clean the canteen. in the crowded canteen we also can meet and greet with our friends in other class.
thaks...
VELLA PRINANDA N.
BalasHapusXII A6/31
Assalamualaikum wr wb
Well, I belong to pro group.Based on my friends's arguments,I think that the students are not allowed to have meal in the classroom. I agree with my group,that is pro group.There are many reasons :
1. Keeping tha class clean
Yes,it's true.If we bring foods to the classroom,of course,the class will be dirty because there any plastics or any covers in the classroom.We usually throw the plastics in tyhe table.Although there is a waste bin in front of the class.We usually put the waste in the table.I do hope that we can keep the school's rule by throwing the waste into the waste bin.It will improve the good habit of the students to keep the class clean
2. Utilization of school canteen
Canteen is a place for drinking and eating so the students must eat and drink at the canteen not in the classroom
3. It is not polite that we eat while teaching learning process -> we don't approciate our teacher.It will make our teacher angry to us
4. Of course,it cannot make us to focus or to concentrate to material well.Our goal in school is to study or get more knowledge guided by our teacher.So,we cannot get the knowledgw optimally
I think that are my speech
Thanks for attention
Wassalam Wr Wb
MUCHAMAD REZA ISMAWAN XII-S1/22
BalasHapusI want to argue Aprilia Dwi Anggraeni
statemet.if you think eating in the canteen was more comfortable in my opinion you are wrong advice.
what if when you are in a state crowded into the cafeteria and finally you do not have a place to eat, whether you eat in the yard or eating in class. whereas if the waste problem in the class was easy to stay we apply picket sesuda grade recess approximately takes 10 minutes so it does not take your rest time
thanks and i hope you reply my answer
MUCHAMAD REZA ISMAWAN XII-S1/22
BalasHapusI want to argue Aprilia Dwi Anggraeni
statemet.if you think eating in the canteen was more comfortable in my opinion you are wrong advice.
what if when you are in a state crowded into the cafeteria and finally you do not have a place to eat, whether you eat in the yard or eating in class. whereas if the waste problem in the after class was easy to stay we apply picket grade recess approximately takes 10 minutes so it does not take your rest time
thanks and i hope you reply my answer
SHABRINA BRILLIAN JALASARI
BalasHapusXIIA7 - 29
Assalamualaikum wr.wb...
ok, thank you previously have given me the opportunity to submit opinions.
I agree with the statement. why? because the space in a school already have their respective functions. And the classrooms are basically serves as a place to eat. we look at the facts alone, the class which is also used for a place to eat, will only reduce the comfort of the classroom for learning activities. so much garbage scattered or food debris that had fallen. to avoid this, the kantinlah the most appropriate place as a place to eat.
do we not know, something to treat it in accordance with the portion that is better? and the portion of the class as a place of learning not a place to eat.
thank you
Ratnasari H. Hamsah (XII - IPS - II / 25)
BalasHapusfor Adam taruna,Your last post are asking why Dwi Purnama Handoko just talking about rubbish, well, we from contra group, from the last at least 3 days, are only get an answer rubbish, rubbish, and rubbish of our rebut for pro group. so, if you're asking why, then ask to your team. . .
Sony Saksono
BalasHapusXIIA6/28
I'm line with this motion because:
1. I think classroom isn't place for eating but it's for studying.
2. If we eat in the classroom , we can our class dirty.
If the class is dirty, we can't comfortable to study.
Ratnasari H. Hamsah (XII - IPS - II)
BalasHapus*additional for Izzatul
so, if you said that we as a students are better have meal in the canteen to minimize the amount of waste in the classroom? and what? just let the canteen full with waste like novrisa said? our school is on the way to get "Adiwiyata" title. if you guys do this, how can our school get that title? anyway if we let the canteen dirty, could you eat your food there comfortably? of course I'm not.
and for your statement about separating the waste, in the fact, the different baskets of waste are in the school area. meanwhile in the canteen there's only a big basket which is freely filled by any kind of waste. so the conclusion is, strictest watch by the teacher for this case is in the school building IN FRONT OF CLASSROOM. right?
Ratih Iza Putri N
BalasHapusXIIA6_22
to Reza Ismawan
I disagree with your argue to Aprilia Dwi Anggraeni that will implement a class break picket approximately takes 10 minutes so do not take your rest time. How could it not take rest time while the rest only 15 minutes. Clearly visible if held picket rest about 10 minutes will be spent rest time.
I think if the school held a rule to not eat in class the school will certainly provide more space for the rest of students. So that students do not eat in class and the class will stay awake clean of junk food.
Thanks
Intan Putri Nattari (XII-IPA-7 / 18)
BalasHapusI'm from pro group with The motion is
"School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom".
I think it is has already clear that students not allow to eat some meal in the classroom,,
why??
1.there are specific place for have meal,it is a "canteen" NOT in the classroom
2.classroom is place for our study
3.if we have meal in the classroom, in the fact, there are many students put the rubbish not in place,,and it can make our classroom dirty
Thank you..
Muhammad Adi Putra (XII-IPA-7 / 20)
BalasHapusAssalamualaikum Wr. Wb.
I agree with this motion is
"School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom".
i think there are many benefit for our life if we can difference about canteen and classroom is good for have meal or not..
1.canteen is the right place for have meal,
2.and classroom is place for our study.
3.so, if we have meal in the classroom,what difference between canteen and classroom,
4.in the fact, many students put the rubbish in everywhere,,and it make our classroom dirty
5.and If our class is dirty, we can't comfortable and serious to study.
Wassalam....
RAFIKA FEBRIANI PUTRI
BalasHapusXII IPA 7-26
I’m from pro group
I agree with the motion because :
1. It is one way of many ways of keeping clean classrooms
2. Besides that, eating in the classroom also showed a bad habit when in the room there are teachers who are teaching
We should have understood what is best for our school hygiene
Amount of garbage in a desk drawer is also the result of eating habits in the classroom which will interfere with our comfort
So should we do it so we always felt comfortable in the classroom
“thanks”
BAKHRUL FADLILLAH AKBAR
BalasHapusXII-IPS 2-10
I argue Rafika's statement :
From you second statement i think it's still can solve like before the teacher teach us sometimes she/he give time for us to clean the classroom.
I think when I have meal in the classroom on lesson time, i feel so comfort and more easy to absorb the teacher explanation.
when we prohibited bring some meal to the classroom it will be inconvenience us because the condition in out of the class so crowded so that uncomfortable to eat some meal
"Si unyil makan sayur lodeh,,,,kecil deh":D
Dwi Intan Maulita
BalasHapusXIIA7 / 12
I agree with this statement because
first, the lesson can be run effectively. students often throw trash under the desk, so that each time learning the teacher asked the class to clean up first. resulting in reduced learning time. whether any change had to clean the class first ??
students who picket the day it's too tired ....
second, to make students more disciplined in carrying out learning activities. students often eat secretly hidden in the classroom when learning takes place.
third, the class to be clean because there is no trash under to desk or on the floor.so it can walk comfortably and can concentrate more on learning.
thank you : )
AMIRULLOH DWI FEBRIYANTO
BalasHapusXII-IPS2-04
School not allow student bring the meal in the class room. This program is one of method to decrease rubbish in the class. So it can make classroom more clean
This policy is not fair for student. It is not fair because it restrict human right student. For example: for student with rich parent, they just need more pocket money to spend in canteen but some student with poor parent , they are given not much money sometimes they just bring some meal from home. And they eat this in class room when the school break.
School not allow student bring the meal in the class room is not in line with education system. In education system explain when the student study the environment must enjoy. Enjoy learning allow student eat some meal in the classroom when the learn happen provided it does not disturb this learn activity.
This policy make school has orientation capitalist and teach the student about capitalist. With this policy, school hope about commodities in canteen realize increase demand. And school gets big profit from they sell commodities.
As a result of this controversy. The school has made the policy more wise than it. Because in the school is not for rich student but for all student. Method for keep clean in classroom not must restrict human rights of student
I'm from group pro.
BalasHapusNino Dwi Ariani Putri XII.A7/22
I agree with the opinion.
"School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom".
Class is a place of learning for students. As much as possible the class should be made as comfortable as possible so that students learn in comfort. Then from that class should be free of any garbage including food waste.
Classroom is a place for students to learn is not the place for a bite to eat. Eating in class to make other students uncomfortable. Let alone eat in class make much trash in a desk drawer that makes dirty. It is therefore a lack of awareness of students' hygiene class. Schools already provide adequate canteen facilities for students to eat and rest. Not something that should be put in place? Canteen to eat, and classes to learn. Because if something does not fit into place to make teaching and learning activities to be ineffective.
"Thank You"
APRILIAN TRI WIDOWATI (XII.A7/06)
BalasHapusI'm from group pro. I will add some arguments for this motion.
I agree with this motion, "School does not allow students to have meal in the classroom".
We can make our classroom dirty if we have meal in there. Although there are a rubbish bin in every in front of our classroom. In the fact, many of students throw the rubbishes in to under the table. Almost every morning when we clean the classroom, we always find many rubbishes in there. We cannot looking for who that throw the rubbish because in our school applied moving class system.
Dirty class can make us not comfortable and serious to study.
We have already a big enough canteen, so why we still have meal in the classroom? And if we go to canteen, we can refresh our mind because if we still in class we feel bored.
Thank you...
Nityasa Manusswara
BalasHapusXIIA7 / 23
iam from pro group,,
i have opinion like this,,
according me, if we eat in class, it can make our class dirty, because many student throwh the rubbish in the under table and the floor. it can make our study uncomfortable. beside that, it can add work picket duty. and if we eat in the canteen, we can refresh our mind with we go to there.we also can meet with our friend from other class and we can eat together.
i think enough for my arguments. thank you
DINDA ANGGERINDA SARI / XII S1 / 09
BalasHapusTo izzatul islam.
Izza, whether eating in the canteen also can minimize waste?
what about the students who usually leave trails of food on the table?
they can only troublesome officer canteen only.
and secondly,
whether capacity can meet all of your student canteen in SMADA?
would not it?
We also will need other places, like in the classroom.
Thank you.
Hilmy Harits XIIA6 / 08
BalasHapuspositive to nityasa,,
beside it can made our class dirty, it also made us become lazier to learn lesson,,, so less knowledge we can get..
and, if we lack of knowledge, we couldn't do the test which given by the teachers,, thank you
Firman Wido XIIA6 / 06
BalasHapusI think what nityasa and hilmy said was right,, but I want to add some negative effect if there are many garbage in the classroom, we will less concentrate to the lesson,,
which can give the same result with what hilmy said, that is we couldn't do the test well
thank you
Muhammad Fauzi
BalasHapusXII-A7 / 21
Assalamualaikum Wr. Wb.
I'm from pro group,,,
I agree with this motion "school does not allow students to have meal in the classroom"...
because :
1.have meal in the classroom can disturb teaching learning process. the students just concentrate to the food, and ignore teachers explanation. if the condition like this, students will get nothing. they just come to school to have meal, not to get knowledge.
2.it make the classroom become dirty. if the students throw away the garbage in the classroom and forget to clean it, it may cause some disease. the garbage in the desk drawer can be the place for mosquitos and fly to lived, and then we could get many diseases such as dengue and diarhea.
3.does not respect the teacher if we are eating in the classroom. so the teacher can angry to ours because of that act.
I think enough...
Wassalamualaikum Wr. Wb.
EKBAR MANDALA PUTRA
BalasHapusXIIS1 / 14
I argue Nino's statement :
We see in fact only, canteen like that whether it can accommodate so many students smada that nearly 900 students, not to mention whether the students who meal in the canteen were throwing trash in its place? I think the same, students who meal di kantin also leave trash on the table, would not that just a hassle canteen staff only.
thank you
Satriyo Ponco Laksono
BalasHapusXIIA6/25
I oppose Ekbar's argument
can you ensure that all smada's students that have their meal in the classroom can put the rubbish in the dustbin?if you can ensure that all smada's students can throw their rubbish in the trash, when will it happen 100% but the fact there still many students of SMADA put the trash not in its place?
Novrisha Anngoro
BalasHapusXIIA7/24
I'm from pro group
I ask to Ekbar and oppose his opinion.
Is there any SMADA's rule that allowed the students have their meal in the classroom?has that rule been written clearly and everyone in SMADA knows about it?
Novrisha Anggoro
BalasHapusXII A7/24
I want to ask Dwi Purnomo Handoko
Could you like to explain to us, what is happening now in our school for those students who have their meal in the classroom and their rubbish?Could you tell the fact please?
Wuri Roro Indraswari
BalasHapusXII A7/ 32
Assalamu'alaikum
I'm Wuri from pro group
I agree if school does not allow students to have meal in the classroom.
I will give my arguments about that
1. school does not allow students to have meal in the classroom to improve the cleanliness. I agree with these rules of these regulations may increase the cleanliness class of the former food waste brought to the classroom.
2. If we have meal in the classroom, the role of the canteen will be reduced. And if we buy food and then bring it to classroom, what for schools struggling to make the broadest canteen.
Conclusion: So, I think have meal in the class is so ineffective because we can not utilize school facilities as well.
Thanks... That’s all my arguments.
LILIK SUCI CENDRANI
BalasHapusXII- IPS - 01/17
I Disagree with Hilmy and firman opinion ,
you say that, the students become lazier to learn lesson because class dirty .
i think you see in negative side
My opinion if we choose have to meal in the class , we have to obey the role of the school that "keep the class clean"
as we know, we enough mature to do it.
the result, the class is not dirty , So we can comfortable learn in the clean class , then we can do the test well.
i think enough
thx. ^^
Nityasa Manuswara H.Y.T
BalasHapusXII A7/23
I want to argue Dwi Handoko
are those your statements have been accompanied by facts that had accompanied by the facts that happened in our school?or it's just your arguments.